The Problem With Human Rights

Channel:Jonas Čeika - CCK Philosophy · Length:24:30 · Published:2019-10-28 · Views:572785

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A philosophy video critiquing the concept of human rights from a Marxist perspective, drawing on Locke, Marx, Nietzsche, Hegel and Rawls. It examines what human rights actually mean and presuppose.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a deeper philosophical look at human rights from a critical Marxist angle.

Jonas Čeika has philosophical deep dive [0] into the topic of human rights worth watching. — HN, 2021

Politics & history (other) · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Human rights today have the kind of status that the divine right of kings had in the Middle Ages. They are so deeply ingrained in our political thinking, that imagining a society without them seems almost impossible. We all know the famous line from the Declaration of Independence: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights," But we should beware of what seems self-evident. In many cases, what seems self-evident is less an indication of what is correct or indubitable, and more an indication of our biases, an effect of the time and place we live in. One of the most influential liberal political philosophers of the 20th century, John Rawls, once even stated that: "Human rights are not the consequence of a particular philosophy, nor of one way among others of looking at the world. They are not tied to the cultural tradition of the West alone, even if it was within this tradition that they were formulated for the first time. They just follow from the definition of justice." That human rights "simply follow from the definition of justice" is, at the very least, a strange claim, because the notion of "justice" has been theorized at least since the ancient Greeks.

On Hacker News

That was a rhetorical question I suppose, in the sense of "whose definition is supposedly the universal one": Jonas Čeika has philosophical deep dive [0] into the topic of human rights worth watching. [0] [VIDEO] — jedimind, 2021-11
No, the entire conception of rights is tied to liberalism, and itself is not the end of human moral ideology. Rights are good compromises: If we all broadly agree that humans are entitled to some right R, then R will become a social institution which we enshrine and protect, and that is good enough for society to make progress and people to get on with their lives. For a deeper look, try this Mar… — Kednicma, 2020-08
Yeah, I had the exact same sentiment. (As in "sure we don't live in a perfect world, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to set goals as a bare minimum baseline".) Oh, here's one more video on human rights [VIDEO] (by Jonas Čeika - CCK Philosophy, a collectivist/Marxist?) — pas, 2024-06

Related videos