The Carbon Offset Problem

Channel:Wendover Productions · Length:22:56 · Published:2022-06-03 · Views:1943886

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Wendover Productions examines why carbon offsets so often fail to reduce emissions, covering specific examples and the perverse incentives in offset schemes.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended in greenwashing and offset threads as a well-sourced, detailed explanation of how offsets underdeliver.

does a much better job than the article of both highlighting specific examples and laying out the perverse incentive structures — HN, 2022

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Climate policy, solutions & debate · Environment, agriculture & food systems

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] in the summer of 2018 western pennsylvania birders ornithologists biologists field tripping teachers appalachian range romantics and trail loving hikers all had reason to celebrate the nature conservancy one of the nation's largest environmental ngos had partnered with the hawk mountain sanctuary to preserve these 2 380 acres of wooded bird habitat some 80 miles or 130 kilometers outside of philadelphia in the grand scheme of things the move wasn't anything major by itself a massive environmental organization preserving an area the size of a small ski town didn't move the needle but the deal was bigger than local interests alone the benefits were global to fund the preserve's protection the nature conservancy partner with bluesource began selling carbon credits and in an effort to offset emissions jpmorgan chase purchased over 96 000 of them it wasn't just corporations buying in either at just 15 a ton individuals bought credits to account for their summer vacations too while smalling scale hawk mountain seemed a perfect project a pragmatic effort that saved important habitat and refuge for local birds and people and provided means for the environmentally conscious to address their own impact on the planet the only

On Hacker News

I think this video by Wendover Productions does a much better job than the article of both highlighting specific examples and laying out the perverse incentive structures that carbon offsetting creates: [VIDEO] Here is the list of sources for that video if you're interested: [1] [LINK] [2] [LINK] [3] [LINK] [4] [LINK] [5] [LINK] [6] [LINK] [7] [LINK] [8] [LINK] [9] [LINK] [10] [LINK] [11] [LINK] … — cowpig, 2022-08
the bigger problem with carbon offsets is that the underlying system that is supposed to be backing the units aren't actually offsetting any carbon. wendover has a nice video on it [VIDEO] — plopz, 2023-08
If you like the video format, Wendover has a very good 20 minute video on the topic, discussing the pitfalls and how non-obvious failure modes of carbon offset schemes can be: [VIDEO] — sofixa, 2023-06
> Carbon offsetting is needlessly and cynically attacked by the same people who talk about wind power killing birds or not recycling the blades. well i don't really understand how you can lump all those together but ok... they're still not the same. as others have pointed out, it doesn't seem hard (or hard enough) to scam in this business sector - i.e. having the same assets accounting for differ… — rmvt, 2023-02
Wendover Productions recently made a very informative video about carbon offsets that goes into much more detail. Certain types of carbon offsets do work, but even those tend to underdeliver. [VIDEO] — Aunche, 2022-08

Related videos