Do Complex Numbers Exist?

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:11:25 · Published:2021-03-06 · Views:854808

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder asks whether complex numbers are just a convenient tool or necessary in physics. She discusses a recent paper arguing that quantum mechanics cannot be done with real numbers alone.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a short, accessible layperson explanation of the real-versus-complex quantum theory debate.

I highly recommend video by Sabine Hossenfelder [1] on this topic. — HN, 2022

Pure mathematics · Quantum physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

When the world seems particularly crazy, I like looking into niche-controversies. A case where the nerds argue passionately over something that no one knew was controversial in the first place. In this video, I want to pick up one of these super-niche nerd fights: Are complex numbers necessary to describe the world as we observe it? Do they exist? Or are they just a mathematical convenience? That’s what we’ll talk about today. Do complex Numbers Exist? So the recent controversy broke out when a paper appeared on the preprint server with the title “Quantum physics needs complex numbers”. The paper contains a proof for the claim in the title, in response to an earlier claim that one can do without the complex numbers. What happened next is that the computer scientist Scott Aaronson wrote a blogpost in which he called the paper “striking”. But the responses were, well, not very enthusiastic. They ranged from “why fuss about it” to “bullshit” to “it’s missing the point.” We’ll look at the paper in a moment, but first I will briefly summarize what we’re even talking about, so that no one’s left behind. The Math of Complex Numbers You probably remember from school that complex numbers are what you need to solve equations like

On Hacker News

I highly recommend video by Sabine Hossenfelder [1] on this topic. She's explaining the topic in layman terms, starting from what does it mean to exist (or be real) in physical sense. Complex numbers, as useful as they are, just an abstraction, a tool which can be replaced with different forms of calculations. That makes the question of "reality" rather complex (pardon the pun). [1] [VIDEO] — viktorcode, 2022-02
This video by Sabine Hossenfelder is probably more informative on this topic: [VIDEO] (it discusses this paper). — ars, 2023-04
There is a nice 10 minute discussion about this paper by physicist Sabine Hossenfelder on her "Science without the gobbelydgook" youtube series (which I recommend). She considers the existential questions regarding necessity of complex numbers a "super-niche nerd fight". You can find the video here [VIDEO] . — johnp271, 2021-12

Related videos