LSV Breaks MTGO

Channel:TCGplayer · Length:4:57 · Published:2012-05-03 · Views:323296

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Pro Magic player Luis Scott-Vargas triggers a mandatory-action infinite loop on Magic Online, and the game stalls in a non-terminating state.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as the real-world example of an inescapable loop in Magic: The Gathering, in discussions of its Turing completeness.

causing the game to wind up in a non-terminating loop of mandatory actions — HN, 2017

Computability & complexity theory · Gaming culture & analysis · Chess, board games & puzzles

On Hacker News

There’s never a time where players can’t interact - just passing priority or putting triggered abilities on the stack are actions. And each time this could happen the game checks state based actions to see if someone has won. That said, if both players have no options or just pass (which is more pronounced online) then you can end up in inescapable loops that cause draws. A classic example is thi… — thom, 2023-12
That rule is exactly where the the construction used becomes interesting: it's built in such a way so that if the turing machine halts, the player who set it up wins the game. If it doesn't, by the rule above, it's a draw. So it's fundamentally impossible to tell the result of an arbitrary setup (and in practice you could set it up such that it halts iff some unknown conjecture is true). Regardin… — rcxdude, 2020-06
> Regarding the oblivion ring loop, there's an example of it being used on MTGO, which doesn't end well (basically seems to crash the server and/or client): [VIDEO] Oh wow, I should have realized that somebody would try it out online just to see what happens! I'm not surprised it ends up with some sort of clash; given that it's Turing complete, the game engine obviously can't detect whether a cur… — saghm, 2020-06
There's also the infamous video of (well-known professional player) Luis Scott-Vargas "breaking" MTGO by causing the game to wind up in a non-terminating loop of mandatory actions: [VIDEO] For those who are confused, the card involved there is Oblivion Ring: [LINK] Its effect is that, when it comes into play, you choose a non-land card in play that gets exiled (removed from play) for as long as O… — ubernostrum, 2017-11

Related videos