I recently learned that waste heat will boil the oceans in about 400 years.

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:22:37 · Published:2023-02-25 · Views:768804

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains that waste heat from ever-growing energy use could eventually boil the oceans in a few centuries, whatever the energy source. She discusses proposed ways to cool the planet.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in energy debates as an illustration of the long-term thermal limits of exponential energy consumption growth.

You might enjoy Sabine Hossenfelder's video exploring this — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Climate science & climate change

Subtitles (excerpt)

Imagine you come home on a cold winter day, take off the gloves, and turn on the heating. You heat with oil and feel a little bad about it, but we’ve got used to that worry. So here’s something new to worry about. What happens with the heat itself? Doesn’t that also, well, heat up the planet? It does. And it *will become a problem, eventually. If that’s true, then why doesn’t anyone ever mention this? Can’t we just build an air condition for the planet? We can, in principle. And that’s what we’ll talk about today. You’ve probably noticed that your phone gets warm when you use it. I hate to break the news to you, but it’s not because it likes you so much. It’s because it’s doing a lot of calculations. Those require energy. The heat is a by-product of using energy. That’s why phones get warm. It’s why lamps get warm, car engines gets warm, and it’s also why power plants of all types get warm. They all emit heat into the environment. And eventually, all that heat warms up the planet, in addition to the heating that we get from greenhouse gases. The reason for this is once again, physics. When we colloquially talk about “energy”, we mean the stuff that comes out of a battery or that we get out of fuel or a power outlet.

On Hacker News

You might enjoy Sabine Hossenfelder's video exploring this "I recently learned that waste heat will boil the oceans in about 400 years": [VIDEO] It turns out we can probably solve this by building planetary chimneys 5km tall that move heat to the outer atmosphere. — alxmng, 2024-06
It’s based on extrapolation of current trends, so I doubt it’ll actually happen. Besides, we’d all die before it got to that. But here are some sources that describe it: [VIDEO] (commentary from Sabrine Hossenfelder, highly recommended) [LINK] [LINK] — nostromo, 2024-01
No matter which energy source you use, increasing energy use will eventually cause problems. With nuclear power, eventually you'll add so much waste heat added to the atmosphere that it will be worse than greenhouse gases: If we continue increasing energy consumption at current rates and cover it with nuclear power the ocean will boil in 400 years: [VIDEO] Obviously that's not meant to be a serio… — audunw, 2024-03
I'm not sure the author realized this, but they're actually making a statement about how crazy exponential growth is. Not about the sustainability of tidal power. This becomes obvious once you look closer at what that 2% growth rate (as assumed in the post) implies. Our global energy consumption in 2008 was estimated to be 474 exajoules. The total energy received by the earth from the sun during … — wcoenen, 2023-09
I think we should start talking about the possible climate impact of waste heat from nuclear thermal power plants too. I'm definitely pro-nuclear, wherever it makes sense, in the short term. As long as it's never at the expensive of building renewables too. But many nuclear proponents talk as if nuclear is the end-goal for power generation. That we should just replace everything with nuclear. But… — audunw, 2023-06

Related videos