Satoshi Has No Clothes: Failures in On-Chain Privacy by Ian Miers (Devcon4)

Channel:Ethereum Foundation · Length:24:19 · Published:2018-12-11 · Views:5036

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ian Miers' Devcon4 talk on failures in on-chain privacy for Bitcoin and Ethereum. It covers attacks on transparent and decoy-based schemes, including how Monero-style privacy can be eroded over repeated transactions.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in Monero and Zcash debates as a critique of decoy-based privacy and its passive and active attacks.

core argument starts at around 10 minutes. — HN, 2021

Cryptography · Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime

Subtitles (excerpt)

really the point of this talk is how do you evaluate privacy in cryptocurrencies the point is not the shells e-cash I am one of the cofounders of Z cash I am on the board of directors of the foundation but that's not why I'm here today the point is that we as a community have done a very poor job evaluating privacy approaches for cryptocurrencies and the problem is that we need to get better at it and we need to get better at it now because at least one of these aetherium bitcoins e-cash something that all of us have ever heard of maybe dogecoin I don't know is going to be the future of payments and it's gonna take a while but at some point when this happens we're gonna realize that this is a major privacy problem we wait until then to actually address it it will be far too late so I've been working on privacy and cryptocurrencies since 2011 for precisely that reason it wasn't clear to me that Bitcoin was gonna succeed but it was clear to me that if it did it was gonna have a pretty big privacy problem and at the time everyone basically believed it was private this was sort of the best logic that everybody had and of course we know now how laughable that is not only are there a bunch of academic research that

On Hacker News

There are multiple attacks in that video. IP is one, but a much bigger one is knowing the real output (or maybe real output plus one other output) among 16 ring signature members. They do not explain how they achieved it but one could guess that maybe by just doing a lot of tx themselves - 15 decoys is just way too small and flooding blockchain with transactions all but ensures that someone picki… — madars, 2024-09
Sure. Starting from the academic beginning and then going to commercial usage: Zerocash[0], a paper from 2014 (I'm an author on it), proposes using zksnarks to get a public ledger + privacy with no centralized parties. Instead of identifying the origin of your money on the blockchain and moving it to someone, you just prove in zero-knowledge your payment is correct. This showed strong privacy on … — ianmiers, 2021-04
>Monero is a [...] untraceable digital cash that preserves privacy Not exactly. A single transaction might be untraceable but over repeated transactions it's possible to deanonymize people with a high degree of confidence. See: [VIDEO] the good part starts at 10 minutes. — gruez, 2021-01
>But for normal usage-as-a-currency, I am a huge believer in XMR (monero), which masks who you're sending money to There was a talk[1] a few years ago that basically argued that this property only really holds if you look at individual transactions in isolation. It basically boils down to: if you make one transaction to a darknet market, it's impossible to know whether you were actually sending t… — gruez, 2021-01
Crypto tribalism aside, you got two technical points fundamentally wrong about the cryptography: 1) snarks are fast now. It takes 3 seconds on a pixel phone for Zcash. 2)The decoy based approaches Monero uses are subject to all kinds of passive and active attacks. Both in practice ( [LINK] ) and just fundamentally: [VIDEO] . There are ways to mitigate some of these problems to a degree. This is w… — ianmiers, 2020-12

Related videos