Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society

Channel:Boston University · Length:1:01:37 · Published:2010-03-30 · Views:317736

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Freeman Dyson's 2005 Boston University talk on heretical views about science and society. He questions prevailing dogmas, including his argument that climate and CO2 are a land management issue.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it for Dyson's contrarian take on global warming and soil carbon.

I encourage you to listen to videos of him. I found him quite enjoyable to listen to. — HN, 2020

Climate policy, solutions & debate · Environment, agriculture & food systems · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

On behalf of the Frederick S. Pardee Center for the Study of the Longer-Range Future, welcome to tonight's lecture, lecture by the Pardee Visiting Professor for 2005 and 6, uh Freeman Dyson. Um like the center itself, this distinguished lecture series was established by the imagination and generosity of Frederick S. Pardee. Freeman Dyson was born in England and received his BA degree from the University of Cambridge. Uh he has spent practically his entire professional life uh as a professor at the Princeton Institute for Advanced Studies, uh from which he only recently retired. Um a winner of the prestigious National Book Critics Circle Award for nonfiction, Professor Dyson has written more than a half dozen books and numerous periodical pieces. Uh he has received honorary degrees from nearly 200 universities. Uh he's a member of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences and a fellow of the Royal Society in Britain. He's won numerous awards, among them the Enrico Fermi Award and the Five at a Kappa Award, the Robert Oppenheimer Oppenheim Memorial uh Prize, the Max Planck medal of the German Physical Society, the Hughes medal of the Royal Society, the Lorentz medal of the Royal Netherlands Academy, the Heineman prize of the American Institute

On Hacker News

I disagree about him hand-waving away quantitative arguments. I’ve watched a number of relatively lengthy interviews and presentations he’s given that have been about or have touched on the topic of climate change, and he consistently references measurements of carbon’s effects and emphasizes the importance of real world measurements. His criticism is of abstract models of climate that attempt to… — didericis, 2020-02
If you feel like watching more hopeful content on the subject, there is Allan Savory's TED talk about how to stop desertification[1], and Freeman Dyson's speech called "heretic thoughts about science and society"[2]. Basically, those speakers suggest climate change is an issue that can be solved with better land management . Soil is extremely good at absorbing Carbon Dioxide. Isn't it why there i… — grondilu, 2017-07
On a related note, Freeman Dyson mentions that an 1/10th of an inch per year of topsoil to the Earths area that currently has soil, would sequester all the carbon all the carbon we release each year. [VIDEO] see around minute 13. — oa335, 2023-02
There is also Freeman Dyson's talk called "heretics thoughts" according to which global warming is mainly a land management issue. [VIDEO] — grondilu, 2018-12
Perhaps a better example would be Freeman Dyson. Here's a video of him talking about questioning the status quo: Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society. [1] In which, he also questions global warming, or at least to the degree in which it will affect us. [1] [VIDEO] — mangodrunk, 2017-03

Related videos