What People Get Wrong About Induced Demand
Channel:Oh The Urbanity! · Length:8:04 · Published:2021-08-29 · Views:291258
Summary
Explains induced demand beyond roads, showing that it applies to transit, walking and cycling infrastructure too but with different consequences. It corrects common misunderstandings of the concept.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as a clear treatment of induced demand across transport modes whenever threads debate road expansion versus transit.
had a pretty good video on induced demand as it applies to both car transit and public transit — HN, 2022
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
Pretty much everyone knows that public transit is more efficient than private cars at moving large numbers of people, but we don't talk enough about just how big the difference is. This is the Don Valley Parkway, a six-lane highway in Toronto. If you sit in one place at rush hour and watch the DVP, you could see 6 to maybe 8,000 people in those cars pass by in the busier direction over the course of an hour. If you do the same thing on the nearby Yonge Subway you could see 30,000 people per direction per hour, with ongoing signal upgrades pushing that up to 40,000 people in the future. That’s an enormous advantage for the subway even before you consider that it only takes up two lanes, mostly underground. Subways don’t carry freight, but when it comes to carrying lots of people, mass transit wins hands down and it’s not even close. We're going to come back to this capacity difference later in the video. If you follow debates about building or expanding roads and highways you’ve probably heard someone bring up the concept of induced demand, often linking explainer videos from places like Vox, (where they use lots of colourful balls to explain), to argue against building the new road or highway. Induced demand, more
On Hacker News
There's a number of key differences, mostly in how things scale with increased use. * Car transit is typically scaled through increased space allocation. Public transit is typically scaled through increased utilization of the same space. * Car transit is limited at about 2000 vehicles/lane/hour. Public transit is mainly limited by the number of buses/trains on a route. (e.g. A typical bus can car… — MereInterest, 2022-01
> Using 'induced demand' for good - I love it. Oh The Urbanity had a good video on this, "What People Get Wrong About Induced Demand": > In this video we explain why induced demand does apply to transit, walking, and cycling infrastructure, but with different consequences. * [VIDEO] Transit, for example, can get better with more ridership: more train capacity is added to a line, and more frequent… — throw0101d, 2024-03
> Cities should be inducing demand for getting around. This is mentioned in the latest NJB video, "More Lanes are (Still) a Bad Thing": > The difference for induced demand for cars, and induced for other modes of travel, is that cars are a extremely space inefficient. You can absorb a lot more induced travel demand on a subway line, tram line, or bicycle path, than you can in a car lane. * [LINK]… — throw0101c, 2024-02
> Did creating the iPhone induce demand for iPhones that otherwise would not have been there? Was there pent up demand for iPhones that was sated by their creation? Invention is the mother of necessity. — Marshal McLuhan > In the same way, it seems strange to term things induced/pent up demand. Increased road capacity means people could plan more car trips without worrying about sitting in traffi… — throw0101a, 2022-04
Related videos
- What People Get Wrong About Dense Urban Living · Oh The Urbanity! · 7:09
- Renting vs. Buying a Home: The 5% Rule · Ben Felix · 10:36
- How the Fed's "Money Printer" Really Works · Ben Felix · 18:01
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- Who Is Responsible For Climate Change? – Who Needs To Fix It? · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 10:36
- This Video Is Sponsored By ███ VPN · Tom Scott · 7:25
- Distinguished Lecturer Series: Building Science - Adventures in Building Science · Berkeley Lab · 1:09:52
- These Stupid Trucks are Literally Killing Us · Not Just Bikes · 35:07
- Jared Mauch - Getting Fiber To My Town (NLNOG Live! September 2020) · NLNOG · 34:42
- International Diversification · Ben Felix · 10:59
- How does a USB keyboard work? · Ben Eater · 34:15
- Detergent packs are kinda wishy-washy (Dishwashers Explained) · Technology Connections · 32:34
- Why American public transit is so bad | 2020 Election · Vox · 9:39
- Forced-air Furnaces: The What, Why, and How · Technology Connections · 22:04
- Ground Source / Geothermal Heat Pumps and Other Info · Technology Connections · 28:04
- I messed up. You're using too much detergent. · Technology Connections · 48:24
- This Swiss Builder uses NO INSULATION... · Matt Risinger · 11:26
- RR #128 - Morgan Housel: The Psychology of Money · The Rational Reminder Podcast · 54:17
- My Squirrel Recording is in a MOVIE! 📽 DUNE: Mark Mangini, Oscar Winning Sound Designer · Dani Connor Wild · 12:13
- ZFS: The Last Word in File Systems Part 1 · Deirdré Straughan · 1:01:26