Stephen Fry on American vs British Comedy

Channel:anc6368 · Length:4:19 · Published:2012-11-12 · Views:4242020

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Stephen Fry explaining the differences between American and British comedy. He attributes them to cultural attitudes such as optimism versus pessimism.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it as an insightful short explanation of why US and UK comedy differ.

Actually very insightful, and explains why I have never been fond of the cool guy — HN, 2022

Social issues & culture · Stand-up & sketch comedy

Subtitles (excerpt)

Um, we have time for one more question, which will come from the gentleman there. Uh, you talked about the sense of humor, the American sense of humor, and we haven't really touched you haven't mentioned so much the British sense of humor, but do you think they differ hugely? And if so, what accounts for that difference? It's a really good point. I think um, I mean, it strikes at the heart of what is American optimism is is a really important thing. But not only optimism, but a um, a a refusal to see oneself in a bad light or, you know, I want one could talk about this for far too long, but but that if you go to an American bookshop, by far the biggest section is self-help and improvement. The you know, the idea that that life is refinable and improvable and that you can learn a technique for anything, whether it's lovemaking, being a businessman, a marriage, cooking, losing weight, uh, whatever it is, there's a there's an NLP way of doing it, there's an Anthony Robbins way of doing it, there's a things they didn't teach you at Harvard way of doing it, there's an unbelievable sense that life is improvable, that you can be lectured at or indeed given a sermon at, you know, that that's it's the Protestant base of America that that things are

On Hacker News

I really like Stephen Fry's take on the difference between American and British comedy: [VIDEO] (YouTube) — rikroots, 2025-03
You must be a fan of American comedy then. Stephen Fry explains the difference here: [VIDEO] Actually very insightful, and explains why I have never been fond of the cool guy that gets all the girls US comedy loves to represent. — sph, 2022-07
That doesn't ring true to me at all. I'm more inclined to agree with Stephen Fry [1], who explains that it's ultimately a matter of optimism versus pessimism. The great American comics are people like John Belushi, the wisecracking charmer who gets the girl in the end, while the British comedian prefers to play the failure; British comedy comes from strife and tragedy and embarrassment and loss o… — atombender, 2022-07
> although as usual the US version stunk I haven't watched the US version but I am reminded of Stephen Fry's explanation of the differences between US and UK comedians[0]. Taskmaster needs contestants willing to embarrass themselves. [0] [VIDEO] — datenhorst, 2021-12

Related videos