The Implementation of Rewind in Braid
Channel:GDC Festival of Gaming · Length:26:56 · Published:2016-12-12 · Views:140955
Summary
Jonathan Blow's GDC talk explains how the time-rewind mechanic in Braid was designed and implemented, including the technical hurdles such as memory limits and state history. It covers both design and engineering concerns.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters cite it as the reference for how a rewind system works and as a point of comparison for undo and serialization approaches.
Here's a GDC talk about the rewind system in which he explains some of the hurdles he had to deal with — HN, 2023
Game design · Game programming & engines
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] okay we'll start whatever um so this talk is implementation of rewind and braid uh it is a technical talk in case you're thinking some kind of design implementation or something that's not it um when I submitted this talk I was like oh sure it's pretty simple I'll be able to talk about everything in 25 minutes it doesn't seem to be how it is there's a lot of little details I won't be able to get into may go a little bit over time whatever feel free to ask me uh by email or something anyway uh who how many people in the room have not played the game all right that's enough Okay cool so I'll show you really quickly uh what it's like it's pretty simple in some ways uh it's a little 2D platformer uh it's shipped on the Xbox 360 PS3 and PC and Mac you run around you know you can jump as you always can you can go into these little worlds where things happen and you know a world this sort of a scrolling area with parallx and all that they can be from one screen to you know eight or 10 screens large there's all these objects that move you know you can get killed and you can rewind like this and uh the rewind is unlimited right it's not a resource and so whoa all right um that was the first of the design goals that I had was I wanted to find out what
On Hacker News
If you're curious how the time rewind was implemented, Blow did a GDC presentation back in 2010. [VIDEO] — OnionBlender, 2023-11
Seconded. It was a great game, albeit with not so much replay value. There is a great interview with Blow on the technicalities of the warping effects in Braid: [VIDEO] In addition to Limbo and Inside, may I also recommend: Portal 1&2 Antichamber VVVVVV increpare.com In particular Stephen Lavelle (@increpare) makes games with much darker and more interesting social implications. Although, Braid a… — m00n, 2018-08
> I don't think that's an earned position. I disagree. > You say he has more credits but only one of those is programming since Braid. He did start a company after that you know. A successful one that makes money and employs people to make art . I don't imagine that running a business takes no time from his life. > But even at the time Braid could have been written in python SDL wrappers and prob… — AnIdiotOnTheNet, 2023-03
Is difficulty of implementation really a reliable indicator for the complexity in players understanding the mechanic? Jonathan Blow did a talk[1] at GDC a few years ago about implementing the time rewind mechanic in his game, Braid. It ended up being a pretty complex system that required a lot of ingenuity to come up with a design and implement it, but the end result is pretty straightforward and… — hbn, 2022-08
It is interesting to compare this to Jonathan Blow's talk on the rewind system in Braid [1]. This stores complete game states using a compression library to keep memory under control, whereas Braid stored a combination of keyframes, and diffs from those keyframes, to avoid using a compression library. [1] [VIDEO] — steeleduncan, 2021-10
Related videos
- Software is in Decline - Jonathan Blow · gamedev cuts · 10:07
- Juice it or lose it - a talk by Martin Jonasson & Petri Purho · grapefrukt · 15:38
- Jan Willem Nijman - Vlambeer - "The art of screenshake" at INDIGO Classes 2013 · Dutch Game Garden · 44:09
- Overwatch Gameplay Architecture and Netcode · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:04:03
- Preventing the Collapse of Civilization / Jonathan Blow (Thekla, Inc) · DevGAMM · 1:02:41
- RustConf 2018 - Closing Keynote - Using Rust For Game Development by Catherine West · Rust Programming Language · 42:29
- A Deep Dive into Nanite Virtualized Geometry · SIGGRAPH Advances in Real-Time Rendering · 1:09:59
- How Crash Bandicoot Hacked The Original Playstation | War Stories | Ars Technica · Ars Technica · 31:37
- Jonathan Blow - How to program independent games - CSUA Speech · Alexandre Franco · 1:15:50
- Ideas about a new programming language for games. · Jonathan Blow · 1:55:24
- Failing to Fail: The Spiderweb Software Way · GDC Festival of Gaming · 59:47
- Exploring the Tech and Design of Noita · GDC Festival of Gaming · 31:00
- Casey Muratori – The Big OOPs: Anatomy of a Thirty-five-year Mistake – BSC 2025 · Better Software Conference · 2:27:33
- 'Diablo': A Classic Game Postmortem · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:17:43
- Miguel de Icaza: Swift Godot: Fixing the Multi-million dollar mistake #GodotCon2023 · Godot Engine · 54:52
- QuakeCon 2012 - John Carmack Keynote · QuakeCon Official · 3:36:38