"NO CGI" is really just INVISIBLE CGI - 1
Channel:The Movie Rabbit Hole · Length:16:30 · Published:2023-10-27 · Views:1533070
Summary
VFX supervisor Jonas Ussing examines what studios mean by "no CGI", showing how much invisible CGI hides behind practical-effects marketing. It is the first part of a multi-part series that includes analysis of doctored behind-the-scenes footage.
Why HN recommends it
Strongly recommended whenever HN discusses CGI, practical effects, or trusting behind-the-scenes footage.
I highly recommend this 5-part essay series — HN, 2025
Animation & visual effects · Filmmaking & video production
Subtitles (excerpt)
Despite the visual effects credits on Hollywood films being longer than ever before If you are to believe the filmmakers they're also using less CGI than ever before. "No one else in the world is doing this level of practical film making and it may never be done again." Everybody loves practical film making, so that's what the studios are giving you "Aviation film like this has never been done and chances are it will never be done again." "It's very important to me that it be practical" One of these days they're going to put "no CGI was used in the making of this film" in the credits right above "no animals were harmed in the making of this film" because that's how important it is for them that you know that they used no CGI. Hi there, my name is Jonas and I have been making visual effects for film and TV for 18 years, and in this 4-part video series we'll be taking a look at all the no CGI there is in Hollywood films today, and that is A LOT of no CGI. So stick around it'll be a lot of fun and I'm saving the best for last. Before we start let's get one thing straight it's fairly easy to agree we all like practical better isn't it? Ignore the music and take a look at these car stunts.
On Hacker News
On the specific no/low-CGI bent — I find the obsession with using this (mostly false) claim so utterly disrespectful to the people in VFX that have poured thousands upon thousands of hours of their lives into the craft, only to be actively derided (or outright denied) by producers hoping to capitalise on whatever this weird obsession is. For anyone that hasn’t seen it but is interested in the top… — Fr0styMatt88, 2026-07
I highly recommend this 5-part essay series "NO CGI" is really just INVISIBLE CGI" [VIDEO] (it starts with "Top Gun: Maverick"). Current-era CGI is insanely good . The problem is that it's used and abused everywhere, often with very little consideration for whether it's needed, or if there's time to do all the VFX shots etc. — troupo, 2025-12
Typically the way it goes is that the studio underplays how much CGI they used during the marketing campaign, while the VFX vendors are forced to bite their tongues, and then 6 months after the movie debuts their NDA expires and they finally get to show how much CGI there really was. This series is a great watch on the subject: [VIDEO] In the later parts there's some really egregious examples whe… — jsheard, 2025-04
This has tended to be significantly overblown recently with a huge amount of 'no CGI' advertising coming from studios, which often verges into utter BS. There's an incredible amount of CG at every level of modern productions, regardless of how much stuntwork and practical effects were done as well. (this video series has a good breakdown on it, which has included studios releasing doctored 'behin… — rcxdude, 2026-04
It's not true either way. Very little is actually practical, it's just that when something looks good people think it is practical because they want to believe that. Marketing feeds into this and tells people movies were done all practical or made "heavy use of practical effects" and it's just lies. This is 5 part series. [VIDEO] Even before this people were saying stuff like mad max was done "al… — CyberDildonics, 2026-04
Related videos
- Over 200,000 Servers in One Place! Visiting Hetzner in Falkenstein (Germany) · der8auer EN · 20:29
- TiTAN - Overdrive 2 (RGB 50fps) - SEGA Mega Drive - Revision 2017 (1st Place) · Oerg866 · 8:24
- Hetzner shows Special AM5 Board with 90° Rotated Socket · der8auer EN · 9:35
- elevated by Rgba & TBC | 4k intro (FullHD 1080p demoscene demo) · Demoscene High-Quality Videos (Annikras) · 3:36
- Old Is the New New • Kevlin Henney • GOTO 2018 · GOTO Conferences · 50:23
- [JSConfUS 2013] Steven Wittens: Making WebGL Dance · JSConf · 30:55
- Self: The Movie; · Jecel Assumpção Jr · 21:01
- Simulating an Entire Car Engine (yes, it makes noise) · AngeTheGreat · 12:03
- Overwatch Gameplay Architecture and Netcode · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:04:03
- I Watched Ancient Apocalypse So You Don't Have To (Part 1) · Miniminuteman · 54:26
- The Beauty of Bézier Curves · Freya Holmér · 24:25
- Ed Catmull, Pixar: Keep Your Crises Small · Stanford Graduate School of Business · 54:11
- "Money doesn't interest me" - Ton Roosendaal 2017 Interview · Blender Guru · 1:46:51
- Jackie Chan - How to Do Action Comedy · Every Frame a Painting · 9:04
- DNA animation (2002-2014) by Drew Berry and Etsuko Uno wehi.tv #ScienceArt · WEHImovies · 7:19
- Captain Disillusion: World's Greatest Blenderer - Live at the Blender Conference 2018 · Captain Disillusion · 41:43