There’s No Wave Function? | Jacob Barandes

Channel:Curt Jaimungal · Length:2:14:30 · Published:2024-11-13 · Views:499142

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Jacob Barandes discusses his view that quantum mechanics can be formulated without wave functions, using a stochastic, probabilistic approach. The long interview covers measurement, the foundations of quantum theory and the history of the field.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a credible, clearly explained alternative take on quantum foundations from a Harvard physicist.

Barandes is excellent at clearly articulating complex ideas in very simple, concise terms. — HN, 2025

Quantum physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

I didn't know it was impossible. So I brought these theories closer and closer together, expecting that there would be a moment when I would need to make some kind of jump to get from one theory, classical physics, to the other theory, quantum physics. And the strangest thing happened. The two cliff faces merged. And there was just no chasm anymore. Today I have a special treat. I traveled to Harvard University to meet in-person Jacob Barendes, the co-director of graduate studies in physics and someone making waves at the intersection of fundamental physics and philosophy. In his unassuming office, he's been working on a revolutionary framework that finally explains quantum mechanics. His radical proposal suggests that there is no fundamental wave function, Hilbert spaces aren't real, and there's no mysterious quantum realm. It's just a mathematical convenience. It's an appurtenance of the theory. But there is no object in physical reality it's describing. In this episode, we go in-depth into the picture that resolves the measurement problem, eliminates the need for multiple worlds, and finally gives a clear view as to what's actually happening at nature's smallest scales. However, this clarity does

On Hacker News

I would recommend watching Curt Jaimungal's series of talks with Jacob Barandes. He gives a nice background history of various aspects of QM, including the formulation of Matrix and Wave mechanics (and loads of other ideas). Barandes is excellent at clearly articulating complex ideas in very simple, concise terms. He also has his own formulation of QM based on "Indivisible non-Markovian Stochasti… — ilitirit, 2025-09
Jacob Barandes is a professor of physics at Harvard (not a crank). He recently did a great podcast with Kurt Jaimungal [1]. In the interview he explains that every year he searches for a good way to introduce his students to quantum mechanics, and every year he's ended up being unsatisfied with the approach and started again. One year he decided to attempt describing systems with traditional mech… — slowmovintarget, 2024-12
I'm convinced there are some semi-classical explanations that just haven't been figured out. Electrons are helically moving photons: [LINK] That's some interesting/wacky stuff, but there has been more research to improve those calculations - like deriving the electron charge and magnetic moment. Personally I like the idea that a proton is somehow literally an electron and 3 up quarks (a neutron g… — phkahler, 2026-02

Related videos