If money was no object, should you run every medical test?
Channel:Medlife Crisis · Length:2:51 · Published:2018-09-02 · Views:263084
Summary
A doctor from Medlife Crisis explains in under three minutes why even a rich patient should not simply order every medical test, touching on pre-test probability and Bayesian reasoning. False positives make blanket testing counterproductive.
Why HN recommends it
HN people link it as a short, funny and accurate explanation of why over-testing and over-screening can do harm.
An under 3-minute video by a funny and informative doctor explaining this — HN, 2021
Probability & game theory · Medicine & infectious disease
Subtitles (excerpt)
it's the early hours of the morning the Sun is rising I'm 32% caffeine by volume so it's time for another minute medicine and this one's actually inspired by a patient I spoke to you tonight to asked a very interesting question which i think is often dismissed as simplistic because it's got a an obvious initial answer and I don't think people take the thought process any further but it's actually a very thought-provoking question and the question is when we don't know what's going on with the patient why don't we just test them for everything and the obvious answer which makes most people dismiss it is that it would cost too much and be impractical but the patient who asked me is actually a real-life multi-millionaire and he asked me in a purely hypothetical sense if he was willing to pay for every test we had in our armament why don't we just send them all off and I actually got thinking about it and realized it's an interesting question no test is perfect every test has a false positive and false negative rate a false positive is where a patient doesn't have a disease but the test says that he or she does and a false negative is the opposite is where patient does have the disease but a test says that they don't now
On Hacker News
An under 3-minute video by a funny and informative doctor explaining this (youtube handle "medlife crisis"): [VIDEO] — tasty_freeze, 2021-05
There's a great (and short) video suggesting why it's not a good idea to run as many medical tests as possible, and it's not because of the cost: [VIDEO] — joosters, 2019-03
I get your point, however I think there are a few confounding things. For a lot of people, if you get a positive result from a test that a doctor brushes off that's not going to go well. I'm very much in favor of more testing personally, there are almost certainly folks who're on SSRIs who'd benefit more from Vit D/Mg supplementation for example. Another thing I seem to remember in his video was … — user_7832, 2024-03
Related videos
- Micro Men - 720p (2009) · gimpymoo · 1:24:12
- (1/4) Intro/History: Introducing a 100-year-old mechanical computer · engineerguy · 3:38
- Sugar: THE BITTER TRUTH · University of California Television (UCTV) · 1:29:36
- We Were Taught to Call Death a Blessing · CGP Grey · 12:43
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Dr. Michael Greger | How Not To Die | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:21:13
- Why Your Vote Doesn't Count · CGP Grey · 6:31
- Why Some Diseases Only Traveled One Direction · CGP Grey · 11:12
- Sunlight: Optimize Health and Immunity (Light Therapy and Melatonin) · MedCram - Medical Lectures Explained CLEARLY · 1:56:10
- Once you understand game theory, you understand the world. · Veritasium · 27:18
- Dr. Jason Fung - 'Therapeutic Fasting - Solving the Two-Compartment Problem' · Low Carb Down Under · 36:10
- The Voting System That Should Replace Every Election · CGP Grey · 4:27
- Minding your mitochondria | Dr. Terry Wahls | TEDxIowaCity · TEDx Talks · 17:46
- Why We Get Fat: And What to Do About It | Gary Taubes | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:27:50
- Fasting For Survival Lecture by Dr Pradip Jamnadas · The Galen Foundation · 1:20:58
- The Epidemic of Fake Disease · Medlife Crisis · 20:57