Robust-first computing: Beyond efficiency
Channel:Dave Ackley · Length:14:46 · Published:2013-09-20 · Views:7878
Summary
Dave Ackley gives a high-level introduction to robust-first computing, which prioritizes robustness over efficiency in computer architecture. A sorting demo illustrates the idea.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as a short, clear explanation of robust-first computing by its originator, and as a philosophy relevant to building with unreliable components like LLMs.
here is a far better explanation by the terms creator — HN, 2021
Subtitles (excerpt)
For the safety of society, and to build really big computers, we should pursue robust-first computing. A system is robust if it tends to do something sensible even when its design assumptions are under stress or violated. Which sounds like a good thing -- you see 'Robust' on feature checklists -- but at the same time, a lot of computer science is about using computer hardware efficiently. And that also sounds like a good thing, but efficiency and robustness are at odds over redundancy which robustness requires, but efficiency eliminates. So for computers out in the real world, for systems meant to have actual responsibility, we should put robustness first, and view maximizing efficiency not as an inherent virtue, but more as a regrettable sometimes necessity. So that's the core message of an essay I've got in the October issue of CACM, and this is a little video intro. So I want to start with a Why do computers crash? I've been asking that question around the country over the last year and a half and people say: bad hardware, bugs, user errors, malware. But the deeper reason is: we made 'em that way. We design computers to freeze up at the first surprise. Why do we do that? Well, as computer programmers, we were counting on there being no surprises--
On Hacker News
Me to, and I'm always battling with the LLM's obsession with lazily writing reams of ridiculously defensive code and masking errors in the code it generates and calls, instead of finding the root cause and solving that. (Yes, I'm referring to the code LLMs generate, not the API for generating code itself, but "fail early and spectacularly" should apply to all code and apis.) But you have to draw … — DonHopkins, 2025-07
You might be interested in 'Robust First Computing' - [LINK] edit: here is a far better explanation by the terms creator: [VIDEO] — nelsonmandela, 2021-01
I am happy you don't agree on modularity. I don't want to be correct, I want to arrive at correct conclusions. :) Composition is great, scale free self similarity is probably the basis for the universe. Modularity is a great design technique, it can also make things weaker and force other (unknowable) design choices because the module boundary prevents the flow of information/force. Overly constr… — sitkack, 2020-01
then you'd debug it, or program debuggers to flit around looking for programmer error then address it the system is clear about its capabilities regarding 'correctness' which seems to imply the programmer's job is to optimise with those built in inaccuracies but what those inaccuracies afford is what ackley is calling robustness and indefinite scalability ackley addresses your question directly w… — justifier, 2015-11
Related videos
- Code Monkey · spiffworld · 3:49
- Wild Tricks for Greenscreen in Blender · IanHubert · 9:50
- MC Frontalot - It Is Pitch Dark · MC Frontalot · 5:09
- Robust-first computing: Demon Horde Sort (full version) · Dave Ackley · 27:12
- Prejudice by Tim Minchin · Tim Minchin · 6:44
- Ted Nelson's Eulogy for Douglas Engelbart · Computer History Museum · 7:25
- Eric Bier Demonstrates Cedar · Computer History Museum · 1:56:07
- World Building in Blender - Ian Hubert · Blender · 35:44
- Unbelievably busy bicycle crossing in Amsterdam · Thomas Schlijper · 9:03
- Rich Harris - Rethinking reactivity · You Gotta Love Frontend · 36:45
- "Weird Al" Yankovic - Word Crimes (Official 4K Video) · alyankovicVEVO · 3:45
- Dasher: information-efficient text entry · Google TechTalks · 53:45
- The Pervert's Guide to Computer Programming Languages - SXSW · Vulk Coop · 1:02:35
- Living Computation: Robust-first programming in ULAM · Dave Ackley · 15:03
- Bret Victor Inventing on Principle · Luna Programming Language Tutorials · 54:20
- Douglas Adams - Hyperland · UJ ObscureMedia · 49:22
- Head Tracking for Desktop VR Displays using the WiiRemote · Johnny Lee · 4:46
- Vibe coding complex changes in Rust · Jon Gjengset · 2:59:07
- CppCon 2015: Bjarne Stroustrup “Writing Good C++14” · CppCon · 1:40:46
- Change w/ Jim Keller · Tenstorrent · 56:53