What Happened to Horses Is Happening to Us

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:15:00 · Published:2014-08-13 · Views:19807892

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey's video "Humans Need Not Apply" argues that automation will make a large part of the workforce economically obsolete, much as engines did for horses. It surveys robots and software replacing both physical and mental labor.

Why HN recommends it

HN has recommended it for a decade as the standard explainer on automation and unemployment, though skeptics later cite it as an example of overconfident predictions.

Excellent video on the subject: CGPGrey - Humans Need Not Apply — HN, 2015

AI safety, AGI & impact · Robotics · Labor, work & inequality

Subtitles (excerpt)

Every human used to have to hunt or gather to survive. But humans are smart...ly lazy so we made tools to make our work easier. From sticks, to plows, to tractors we’ve gone from everyone needing to make food to, modern agriculture with almost no one needing to make food — and yet, we still have abundance. Of course, it’s not just farming, it’s everything. We’ve spent the last several thousand years building tools to reduce physical labor of all kinds. These are mechanical muscles. Stronger, more reliable, and more tireless than human muscles ever could be. And that's a good thing. Replacing human labor with mechanical muscles frees people to specialize and that leaves everyone better off - even those still doing physical labor. This is how economies grow and standards of living rise. Some people have specialized to be programmers and engineers whose job is to build mechanical minds. Just as mechanical muscles made human labor less in demand so are mechanical minds making human brain labor less in demand. This is an economic revolution. You may think we've been here before, but we haven't. This time is different. ## Physical Labor When you think of automation, you probably think of this: giant, custom-built, expensive,

On Hacker News

This article just leans on the same historic analogies that don't hold up to scrutiny. These answers fall way short of the effect of automation and AI will have. You are not replacing the job with another, you are replacing the human brain! I always refer people to this video to explain what it will be like, and it debases almost all the points made in this FAQ: [VIDEO] All these historical analo… — noetic_techy, 2016-12
This reminded me of the "Humans need not apply" video, which I strongly recommend, if you haven't already seen it: [VIDEO] Discussion: [LINK] — csl, 2015-11
And people who refuse to see it are usually blind... The supermarkets I go to have greatly reduced their cashiers. In most cases by at least half, especially in small shops (3 cashiers has become 2-3 machines and one human). As for bakers, they don't just make bread and cake. Excellent video on the subject: CGPGrey - Humans Need Not Apply: [VIDEO] — scrollaway, 2015-09
I highly recommend CGP Greys video ( [VIDEO] ) for a good overview of the issue. See [LINK] for similar discussion. — polymatter, 2015-04
Easier said than done. What are they going to retrain to? As AI continues to advance, more and more jobs will necome redundant. CGP Grey did a great video on this[1]. Even if you can't completely replace humans, often times, obe person will be able to do the job that used to take several. Where do those others go? What will we as a society do if for example AI-based Expert Systems make 90% of acc… — zyx321, 2014-12

Related videos