Suburbia is Subsidized: Here's the Math [ST07]

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:10:15 · Published:2022-03-07 · Views:1461986

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes explains, using Urban3's property-tax analysis, why car-dependent suburbs generate less tax revenue than they cost to maintain, so dense urban cores effectively subsidize them. It is part of a Strong Towns series.

Why HN recommends it

The go-to link in urban planning threads for the claim that suburban infrastructure costs more per resident than it pays back.

Good overview of the research on this — HN, 2022

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

This is the city of Lafayette, Louisiana. It’s a pretty typical mid-sized American city. Like most American cities, it has that one nice old building that didn’t get bulldozed in the 60s. And like most American cities, it’s broke. It’s full of ageing infrastructure in desperate need of repair, and not enough money to maintain it. But unlike most American cities, Lafayette acknowledged this fact, and requested the help of Strong Towns, and Urban3, a consulting company that helps cities better understand the economic impact of development. Their analysis in Lafayette uncovered a harsh reality that should be a wake-up call to every municipality in North America As well as any city emulating the American car-centric style of development. But let’s back up a bit. In a previous video in this series, we discussed how two identical lots in the same city have very different property tax revenue. In this example, a 100-year-old commercial block, built in the traditional style of development, drastically outperformed a shiny new development, created in the modern car-centric style. But despite the differences in revenue, both blocks have the same cost to the city to maintain their infrastructure.

On Hacker News

Well, you're parking it in other places as well, I assume, unless you're only making pleasure rides with no stops at all. I am speaking more generally than just about your particular situation, which I obviously don't know. But in case you live in an American suburb: their entire financial setup is unsound, which arguably means even your own ground is subsidized. I find the arguments of Strong To… — gpvos, 2026-02
No, suburbs cost more per capita than people living in the inner city, generate less tax revenue and end up becoming a net negative to municipalities: [VIDEO] The whole series of videos from Strong Towns are good, you should take a look: [LINK] — rglullis, 2025-09
Curious, have you considered the in-between here? Consider medium-density European cities, which still have massively higher density suburbs, but rarely the density -- combined employment and population densities -- of the urban core of most American cities. I hated living in Seattle, but I'm now an American finding I enjoy living in London. I walk around trees and birds every day, because I have… — jwestbury, 2023-06
If we taxed suburbs by how much they actually drain city budgets, no one would want to live in suburbs. It is by now a well-studied fact that suburbs are effectively subsidized by metropolitan cores. Makers and takers, indeed... Here's a video about some of the studies done to come to this conclusion: [VIDEO] The folks at Strong Towns also talk a lot about productive land use measured as property… — uoaei, 2023-01
Because "Office Vacancy Rate in San Francisco Just Hit a New High", That means property owners aren't making money. Workers aren't out spending to come in, stay and leave. All that is taxable, which is why government officials want people back in the office. In every city, the downtown core's tax revenue subsidizes the suburban sprawl all around it. Good overview of the research on this: [VIDEO] — downrightmike, 2022-10

Related videos