Why American Cities Are Broke - The Growth Ponzi Scheme [ST03]

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:9:39 · Published:2021-01-11 · Views:3851334

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes explains the Strong Towns argument that car-dependent American suburbs cost more to maintain than they generate in taxes. It describes the growth Ponzi scheme that props up municipal finances.

Why HN recommends it

HN keeps pointing to it as the clearest explanation of how low-density infrastructure is financed and why it is unsustainable.

I can't recommend this video [1] by Not Just Bikes enough. — HN, 2022

Macroeconomics & financial crises · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

Welcome to the third video in my Strong Towns series. If you have no idea what Strong Towns is about, you might want to watch the first two videos, but it's not strictly necessary. American cities are famous for car-dependent sprawl. That's probably one of the first things most people associate with America, after apple pie, baseball and driving in soul-crashing traffic. But this wasn't always the case. American cities don't have to be sprawling just because the country itself is big. And up until the Second World War, they weren't. They were just as compact as cities found almost anywhere else. But after the 1940s, America started on a totally different pattern of development, and began their great suburban experiment. But herein lies the problem: because this American pattern of development builds places that do not financially support themselves. And the only reason they're still there is because American cities are a Ponzi Scheme. If you don't know what a Ponzi Scheme is, there are many videos on YouTube, but a very quick explanation is as follows: A scammer offers an imaginary investment opportunity, offering a huge return on investment. Investor A comes along and invests. Now, the scammer doesn't actually have the money

On Hacker News

> Do you have a citation for this? I don't have a citation for construction costs, and I will concede that there are many factors that may make some low density developments cheaper per unit then some higher density development. However, construction is only part of the picture. Low density development imposes terrible financial costs for cities that contain them. That's because the taxable value… — ARandumGuy, 2022-08
I don't think you understand how much it costs to maintain the infrastructure to your house. Not Just Bikes did an excellent series on this specific problem. [VIDEO] — kd913, 2022-03
In large parts of the United States it should affect single-family homes. A lot of cities constructed their suburbs with one-term fees and subsidies, but are charging extremely low taxes on the houses once constructed. In fact, the taxes are so low that they don't pay for the upkeep of the infrastructure required to service those houses. They are losing money on every house and are trying to make… — crote, 2024-06
It is indeed the system, and you (to no fault of your own, probably) are part of that system. NotJustBikes, while a little anti-car-propogandaey for my tast, does a good just explaining why it'd be basically impossible for suburbia to ever pay for itself: [VIDEO] — kdmccormick, 2023-11
> Those costs aren't really all that high, and are easily outweighed by the dramatically lower costs in the suburbs. Everything is cheaper there, land, buildings, repairs, goods and services. He's talking about infrastructure cost (how much it costs your municipality to provide the services that you use, like the roads) while you are talking about cost of life (how much it costs you to pay for ot… — otikik, 2023-11

Related videos