Which key is the saddest?

Channel:Adam Neely · Length:9:07 · Published:2017-01-09 · Views:1288837

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Musician Adam Neely examines whether certain keys sound sadder than others, looking at the history of tuning systems and temperaments and at how instrument timbre shapes the emotional character we hear. It draws on historical aesthetics writing and audio examples.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it for its historical context on tuning systems and for how instruments influence what music gets composed.

lots of historical context about tuning systems, but also raising the issue of timbre of specific instruments — HN, 2020

Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] you are listening to the Prelude to the second Bach Cello Suite the chist is the great rosovich who would speak of the suite's sorrow and intensity another great chist Pablo Cals would write of the tragic feeling evident throughout the second Suite this piece of music was written around the time that Bach's first wife Maria Barbara died suddenly and you can really hear the grief and sorrow in the music after all the second Cello Suite was written in the key of D Minor which as we all know D Minor which I always find is really the saddest of all keys but is it do different Keys really sound different historically composers really have felt that there has been a discernable difference between keys in his musical Treatise ideas towards an aesthetic of music Christian friedrick Daniel schubar came up with a detailed list of keys and the unique feelings associated with key right away we run into some interesting nuggets like this one EF flat minor feelings of anxiety of all of the Soul's deepest distress from being lost in daydreaming despair of blackest Melancholy of the Soul's gloomiest condition every fear every hesitation of the shuttering heart breathes from the shocking E flat minor If ghosts could speak they

On Hacker News

If you're into that, check out Adam Neely's channel. There's been a few videos on that and related topics: [VIDEO] (Spoiler: lots of historical context about tuning systems, but also raising the issue of timbre of specific instruments) — viraptor, 2020-05
I recommend checking out Adam Neely's channel, where he touches on some similar concepts: [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — mafuyu, 2018-09
Re #2, I'm not a programmer, but as a writer I find the same thing to be true. I work better with a pen and legal pad than a keyboard. I've got this feeling that we have neural pathways built for typing and, subconsciously, we favor phrases, words, and sentences that are easy to type. I know I even have a tic where if I pause to think I'll insert extraneous commas. It's kind of like how musicians… — abakker, 2018-04

Related videos