Benno Rice: The Tragedy of systemd -- BSDCan 2018
Channel:BSDCan · Length:32:29 · Published:2018-08-06 · Views:25547
Summary
Benno Rice's BSDCan 2018 talk on why systemd exists and what it got right and wrong. It traces the history of Unix init and why Linux distributions adopted it, while asking what the BSDs should learn.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as a balanced, eloquent take on the systemd debate that even skeptics find persuasive.
One of the better videos on this subject — HN, 2019
Operating systems & kernels · Linux & open-source ecosystems
Subtitles (excerpt)
all right can people hear me up the back if I speaking about this yep excellent good right all right so I would just like to initially thank everyone on ESP cam for inviting me to speak in front of all of you lovely people and in full understanding and acknowledgement of that thanks I would like to present a live reading on pizzelles by the dazzled by blockchain by Michael sorry no George Neville Neil could not be here so and it wouldn't feel right doing this without him which which is a tragedy link so I came up with the name of this talk around the same time that I came up with the first sort of rough idea of it and it seemed to fit really well especially when I went to Wikipedia and saw that you know tragedy is a form of drama based on human suffering that invokes an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in audiences and I think it was plenty of drama in here and suffering to go around in systemd and so I figured that it was it was a good way to go another thing that really came into it when I was developing this talk is this piece by Oren Shaw called content culture it's a really interesting piece and it's kind of confronting sometimes because in a lot of the communities that were in part of the way that we show that we're in the
On Hacker News
> After listening to the BSD Canada talk on systemd and BSD For someone who don't know, here is the video "The tragedy of systemd". This is a really good talk. [VIDEO] — kbumsik, 2019-10
A nice talk that might change your view of the subject is the following: [VIDEO] . It's a video from BSDCan, the Canadian BSD conference. Even some BSD people are realizing that systemd has a good point to exist! — znpy, 2019-09
One of the better videos on this subject: [VIDEO] BSDCan 2018—Benno Rice: The Tragedy of systemd "systemd is, to put it mildly, controversial. Depending on who you ask it's either a complete violation of the UNIX philosophy, a bloated pile of bugs, a complete violation of the elegant simplicity it replaced or, it most cases, some or all of the above. So why have so many Linux distributions taken … — sjwright, 2019-05
>Personally, I never found startup time to be much of a problem, on any OS. Well, start up problem is a matter of convenience, it's not a fatal problem, but I just like that my laptop with arch+systemd+systemd-boot starts instantly (3 seconds + 6 seconds for firmware), while bsd on my other laptop starts soo damn slow. (btw slow shutdown pisses me off even more) Though the real issues with rc are… — ernst_klim, 2018-11
> Tacitly: most people don’t like launchd, but they don’t interact with it either. Find me a person who writes or debugs launchd plists and you’ll find that: > [...] > 2. they don’t like launchd This is true in my case, although the main thing on my mind when I work with launchd my main complaint often boils down to 'I wish this were more like systemd'. IME, systemd has much nicer CLIs, more capa… — pxc, 2024-08
Related videos
- Simon Peyton Jones - Haskell is useless · bunidanoable · 6:23
- The Mother of All Demos, presented by Douglas Engelbart (1968) · Marcel · 1:40:52
- Complete Apple WWDC | Steve Jobs talk and answer developers questions | 1997 · TheAppleFanBoy - Apple & Computer Archives · 1:11:16
- Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius · Tantacrul · 21:35
- Gtk to Qt - a strange journey [linux.conf.au 2014] · Konstantin Bläsi · 46:05
- Leaping the chasm from proprietary to open: A survivor's guide · Bryan Cantrill · 43:28
- The Tragedy of systemd · linux.conf.au · 47:18
- The Thirty Million Line Problem · Molly Rocket · 1:48:55
- VCF East: Ken Thompson interviewed by Brian Kernighan · Vintage Computer Federation · 1:03:51
- The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013) · Mladen Mijatov · 45:35
- LISA11 - Fork Yeah! The Rise and Development of illumos · USENIX · 1:04:03
- Tech Talk: Linus Torvalds on git · Google · 1:10:15
- USENIX ATC '21/OSDI '21 Joint Keynote Address-It's Time for Operating Systems to Rediscover Hardware · USENIX · 1:06:19
- AT&T Archives: The UNIX Operating System · AT&T Tech Channel · 27:27
- DebConf 14: QA with Linus Torvalds · Adnan Hodzic · 1:11:43
- Unix and Google · FOAM · 7:15