"Energy Revolution? More like a Crawl" - Dr. Vaclav Smil

Channel:Trottier Institute for Sustainability in Engineering and Design · Length:1:48:55 · Published:2015-09-20 · Views:59255

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Energy scholar Vaclav Smil argues that global energy transitions are slow and that renewable targets should not rest on wishful thinking. He appraises how energy dependencies are likely to change and asks for using much less.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a grounded, data-driven counter to hype about quick energy revolutions.

I really suggest watching this talk by Smil — HN, 2018

Climate policy, solutions & debate · Renewables, batteries & storage · Earth & energy (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

boswa good evening welcome everyone to this uh special seminar event uh energy Revolution uh more like a crawl uh by distinguished speaker vaslav smill it's wonderful to see such a nice turnout uh I know we have here in the audience uh representatives from just about every University campus uh in Montreal so from concard University the HC poly technique um university moral and ukam so thank you all for showing up so um I'm subasish kosal I'm a professor in Mel's faculty of engineering and director of the Trot Institute for sustainability and engineering and design which we call tiet short and tonight's event is part of the fasio 3E speaker program and is co-hosted with tyed so a bit of background here on fasia 3E and the collaboration with tyed Miguel's partnership with fontasia 3E began about 5 years ago looking back I'm very pleased to say that this relationship has grown over the years and has directly supported Ted's own mission we at taed share fasio 3's core beliefs that energy literacy is a pillar of sustainable engineering that integrative and collaborative design work of uh Engineers Architects and urban planners is required to reduce energy consumption in the urban envelope and the transition to non-emitting energy sources is an very important task

On Hacker News

Exactly, we haven't achieved that much actually. Most of the technology we use for harvesting energy is not much further from what people could imagine in 19th century. Turbine was invented in the 19th century. I really suggest watching this talk by Smil [VIDEO] and if you are interested reading some books from him about energy and oil. Really insightful. — Scea91, 2018-08
I encourage you to look at the work of Vaclav Smil [1] . There's no such thing as clean energy. [1] [VIDEO] — lcamach84, 2020-09
That is a bizarre claim to make. Energy will not be far cheaper and more abundant in 10 years. Trillions of dollars are invested in infrastructure that has lifetimes of 50+ years. It is not economically or technologically feasible to undergo an energy revolution that quickly. Even if we gathered the political and financial will, our production facilities and supply chains could not feasibly handl… — tedsanders, 2017-05
I get where you're coming from, folks like Vaclav Smil have talked about how the haber bosch process is arguably what's kept 2/3 of human population alive ( [VIDEO] ). The issues are also: - Thinking beyond the anthropocentric and realize we've created many ocean dead zones: e.g. [LINK] . Think about what this'll mean in terms of ocean temperature in life within our lifetimes. - Many farmsites si… — seltzered_, 2022-12

Related videos