The Expert Myth

Channel:Veritasium · Length:17:58 · Published:2022-08-02 · Views:16081474

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium examines which experts have real expertise, drawing on chess research and work by Klein and Kahneman. It explains that expertise comes from pattern recognition built through deliberate practice in valid, feedback-rich environments.

Why HN recommends it

Frequently recommended in threads on learning, the 10,000 hours rule and deliberate practice as a clearer account of how expertise develops.

Veritasium has a really good video on the subject [0], with a much more compelling explanation for what it takes to develop expertise. — HN, 2024

Psychology & human behavior · Chess, board games & puzzles · Education & learning

Subtitles (excerpt)

- Do you bring this trick out at parties? - Oh no. It's a terrible party trick. Here we go. 3.141592653589793 - This is Grant Gussman. He watched an old video of mine about how we think that there are two systems of thought. System two is the conscious slow effortful system. And system one is subconscious. Fast and automatic. To explore how these systems work in his own head, Grant decided to memorize a hundred digits of pi. - Three eight four four six... - Then he just kept going. He has now memorized 23,000 digits of pi in preparation to challenge the north American record - .95493038196. That's 200. (Derek laughs) - That's amazing. I have wanted to make a video about experts for a long time. This is Magnus Carlsen, the five time world chess champion. He's being shown chessboards and asked to identify the game in which they occurred. - This looks an awful lot like Tal V Botvinnik. (playful music) - Whoops. - Okay. This is the 24th game from Sevilla obviously. (chuckling) - Now I'm going to play through an opening. And stop me when you recognize the game. And if you can tell me who was playing black in this one. Okay. (playful music) I'm sure you've seen this opening before. - Okay. It's gonna be Anand.

On Hacker News

It's absolutely pseudoscience. 10k hours doing what ? And why would we expect to see an approximately equal amount of time to achieve expertise across so many different human endeavors? Veritasium has a really good video on the subject [0], with a much more compelling explanation for what it takes to develop expertise. He comes up with 4 things, but the two that stood out the most to me are that … — lolinder, 2024-12
Deliberate practice is a well studied phenomenon. My favourite talk in the subject is this one from Veritasium [VIDEO] — angarg12, 2023-07
Derek from Veritasium had a pretty good video on becoming an expert in anything and I didn't see age as a blocking factor. I'd say go for it! Also check out the video here, it's worth a watch [VIDEO] — Zensynthium, 2022-10
The Veritasium youtube channel has a few interesting videos related to this topic: This one is on IQ: [LINK] Pay attention to the stats on how IQ correlates to success (near the end). This one is about becoming an expert: [VIDEO] This one is about someone who just worked harder than everyone else: [LINK] — swframe2, 2024-02
I'd also add this standard. Another amazing YouTuber is Veritasium. He went from [1] to [2]. The production quality is more than slightly improved, but the "spirit" remains identical. And I think that spirit is what drives success or failure. The production quality is just icing. [1] - [LINK] [2] - [VIDEO] — somenameforme, 2023-03

Related videos