The Only Unbreakable Law

Channel:Molly Rocket · Length:53:25 · Published:2022-03-16 · Views:488899

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Casey Muratori's lecture, originally given at the Technical University of Madrid, arguing that Conway's Law is the only viable candidate for a true law of software architecture. He explains how software mimics the organization over time, using examples like Windows' multiple volume controls.

Why HN recommends it

HN treats it as the definitive explanation of Conway's Law and links it in almost any thread about org structure shaping software.

Casey Muratori has an excellent lecture on this same topic — HN, 2023

Software architecture & design · Management, leadership & organizations

Subtitles (excerpt)

any time i'm giving a lecture to students one of the things that i'm always kind of afraid of and i think everyone should be is that students if they go on to a long programming career will be programming for like 40 years and i've already been programming for 40 years and i know that any kind of advice or information or things that people say are true 40 years ago often aren't true even a few years after let alone for all your entire programming career so for this lecture i kind of wanted to try and figure out is there anything that i could say about software architecture which is primarily what i work on day to day and what i think most about is there anything i could say that i've ever seen that approximates an actual like law like something i don't think will ever break so that if you learn to think about it and apply it every day in how you view software architecture and architecture in general that you'll never really have to update it maybe you'll refine it but you'll never really have to update it so first i want to try and tell you what is a law like what do i actually consider a law to be and we can look to other domains and figure this out really quickly we all know what a law is in physics here for

On Hacker News

If you want to dig into Conway's law and its implications, I can't recommend this video essay by Casey Muratori enough: [VIDEO] Fair warning though, you'll lose all hope that companies like Microsoft will ever manage to produce anything that they don't then ruin. — krig, 2024-03
Casey Muratori has an excellent lecture on this same topic, which draws many of the same conclusions as this article but goes into more depth on why it happens and what it means to you in a practical sense. ( [VIDEO] , skip to 15:30 as the beginning is about setting up the idea of software laws, discussing other candidates for strong software laws, and the history of the law.) The Cliffs notes if… — fwlr, 2023-07
Some great examples in "Conway's Nightmare" [VIDEO] My favorite from memory is that Windows now has five completely different volume control UIs, each of which can be traced directly to distinct product teams and their organizational dynamics across time. This video makes goes futher and says that the evidence for Conway's law is not only strong but has yet to be disproven; the closest we can get… — perrygeo, 2023-04
I found this video [0] recently by Casey Muratori that really helped me understand why Windows is the way that it is. It's about Conway's law in software development and software architecture, but he explains it with anecdotes about Windows, like how vendor communication challenges lead to 4 different volume sliders. I would pass on an expensive heavy-partnership Windows device. [0]: [VIDEO] — randusername, 2026-06
“Time” is the answer almost always. Standards evolve over time, as do the languages and frameworks. Old code is rarely rewritten, so you end up with layers of code like geological strata recording the history of the developer landscape. There’s a more complicated aspect of “Conway’s law, but over time ” that’s hard to explain in a comment. And anyway, Casey Muratori did it better: [VIDEO] — jiggawatts, 2025-01

Related videos