Gaslighting Your Fans w/ Dolby ATMOS™
Channel:Benn Jordan · Length:24:13 · Published:2023-06-05 · Views:892608
Summary
Musician and audio engineer Benn Jordan tries Dolby Atmos as a consumer, covering the theory of immersive audio, its business model, and home theater and headphone listening. He concludes it often falls short of the pitch.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it in Atmos and spatial audio threads as a knowledgeable critique of why the format rarely delivers.
I found this video by Benn Jordan very enlightening about the whole Atmos nonsense — HN, 2023
Audio & video engineering · Music theory, synthesis & production
Subtitles (excerpt)
musicians Red Alert everything's about to change Atmos is the new standard that your listeners want you're going to have to upgrade your speakers your headphones your audio interface your VST plugins and you're probably going to have to buy a Mac and you might just have to take everything that you know about mixing and engineering and throw it out the goddamn window and if you can't afford to do all that then get richer music fans I have some great news technology has finally allowed you to listen to music the way that your favorite musicians want you to hear them in immersive 3D sound with Dolby Atmos and all you need to do is switch your upgrade streaming services by somewhere between 7 and 40 speakers and a new receiver and of course you're going to want to have a room in your house that fits dolby's specifications and you're always going to want to sit in the exact same spot when you listen to music but otherwise you're not listening to music the way that it's meant to be heard and that is ew now before we dive in and open this hair can of worms I noticed that a lot of times when somebody criticizes Atmos the goal post just keeps moving or their credibility is doubted so I'm just gonna say it if you are
On Hacker News
Someone else posted this down in the bottom of a comment thread somewhere, but I think it deserves to be at the top level: [VIDEO] This is a smart, motivated audio engineer talking about Atmos. Quick summary: it's awful when it works perfectly, and it almost never works perfectly, in fact, it rarely works at all. Good luck trying to get Atmos working, and even if this was a completely open standa… — philovivero, 2023-07
I imagine it's seen as a value-add by Apple and Dolby. Studios are forking off massive sums to build-out Atmos rigs. A savvy artists may ask for it because it helps you on Apple Music. As for the consumer experience, I feel like Benn Jordan's video from earlier last year does a good job of explaining the situation and its current limitations: [VIDEO] — spamizbad, 2024-01
I found this video by Benn Jordan very enlightening about the whole Atmos nonsense: "Gaslighting Your Fans w/ Dolby ATMOS" [VIDEO] TL;DW: It's just not worth it. (but do watch it to understand why) — TonyTrapp, 2023-08
You can get very cheap digital to digital audio hardware that can convert any multi-channel audio stream (DRM or otherwise) to straight multi-channel PCM. I personally, occasionally, use an RME Babyface Pro (not cheap) for this purpose, but there are many options available. You can even do this purely in software. On Windows or Linux look at Jack. On MacOS I guarantee it's available. As an aside,… — Intermernet, 2023-07
[LINK] tl;dr New surround tech with added height channels. Great. I can imagine there could be uses. Like any new tech before you've analysed it, could be good, could be trash. Additional surround height channels cannot possibly be as good as 2 channels, properly recorded and mixed to drive stereo headphones for generating 3D sound. This is key. You can't beat headphones for 3D sound. If you can'… — harry8, 2023-07
Related videos
- The Antique Microwave Oven that's Better than Yours · Technology Connections · 14:20
- Emulating the DX7 the HARD way · plgDavid · 18:40
- MC Frontalot - It Is Pitch Dark · MC Frontalot · 5:09
- OK Go - This Too Shall Pass - Rube Goldberg Machine - Official Video · OK Go · 3:53
- The Daily Show - Gun Control Whoop-de-doo (ft. John Oliver) · Comedy Central · 5:22
- D/A and A/D | Digital Show and Tell (Monty Montgomery @ xiph.org) · FL Studio · 23:52
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius · Tantacrul · 21:35
- Trackers: The Sound of 16-Bit · Ahoy · 41:11
- Functional Composition - Chris Ford · ClojureTV · 39:21
- Intro to Synthesis Part 1 - The Building Blocks of Sound & Synthesis · matrixsynth · 56:11
- The world's worst video card? · Ben Eater · 32:47
- The Marvel Symphonic Universe · Every Frame a Painting · 13:35
- Notation Must Die: The Battle For How We Read Music · Tantacrul · 1:16:21
- DOOM: Behind the Music · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:00:57
- Floyd Toole - Sound reproduction – art and science/opinions and facts · CIRMMT · 1:13:56