Rant: Entity systems and the Rust borrow checker ... or something.
Channel:Jonathan Blow · Length:1:00:52 · Published:2018-09-14 · Views:305290
Summary
Jonathan Blow's hour-long livestreamed response to a RustConf 2018 closing keynote about entity systems in Rust. He argues that index-based entity systems amount to manual memory management that sidesteps the borrow checker, and he talks about friction for game developers.
Why HN recommends it
It is the standard citation in HN arguments over Rust for game development, the borrow checker and ECS designs, as a skeptical view from an experienced game developer.
A more detailed description of his opinions are laid out here where he goes into much more detail — HN, 2020
Programming language design · C, C++, Rust, Go & systems languages · Game programming & engines
Subtitles (excerpt)
So, this morning, I woke up and there was a video online from Rust Conf 2018, which I didn't know was a thing, but that's a thing, where they talk about Rust, the programming language, not the game. Uh and there was a video on there uh called Using Rust for game development by Katherine West from Chucklefish. And I watched it and I have some disagreements with it that I'm going to want to talk about uh today. Um they're not um I you know, they're not internet flame bait caliber disagreements. Some of them people might think are pretty subtle, but they're important because they get down to the foundations of how do you want to program and how do you make sure your program is correct and uh you know, if you're designing a programming language, how does the programming language help you know that your program is correct and all these things, right? And so, I just wanted to go through and hit the the major points of what I disagree with. Um I'll say, you know, in the beginning so that people don't get the wrong idea, uh I think that overall it's a good talk and that people would learn uh from watching it. It's just there's there's just some things uh that I got to talk about. So, let me um I'm going to bring the video up for a second.
On Hacker News
I find that Jonathan Blow ranting about Rust game development here [VIDEO] . He adds interesting perspectives to the discussio, how the language makes the Rust game developer resort to arrays and their so called Rust point of views. — colund, 2024-04
These discussions always remind me of some talks by Jonathan blow where he argues rust doesn’t solve the hard problems he needed it to. There are podcast episodes with better discussions, but the main one people link to seems to be this I haven’t used rust, but I sympathize with his problems with pointers and learned a lot from the various ways people try to solve them [VIDEO] — hertzrat, 2022-09
Pointers living through a render pass aren't the main use case he is interested in. It's a problem space that many engineers are familiar with so it's easy to talk about. Game developers have some very domain-specific problems that are less common outside of game engines. A more detailed description of his opinions are laid out here where he goes into much more detail about his experiences portin… — gravypod, 2020-02
> What features in Jai make it superior to C++ for writing games specifically? I know that Jonathan Blow can be abrasive and one-sided in his talks on programming, but I think we should be open-minded about Jai. Yes, he is making this language because he doesn't like C++, but you make it sound like he is hating on C++ just for the sake of it. I mean, is it really so hard to imagine that someone m… — matthewkayin, 2025-12
There's also the fact that a lot of patterns that are commonly used in game development are fundamentally at odds with the borrow checker. Relevant: [VIDEO] — bakugo, 2025-08
Related videos
- Locksmith ripoffs: Hidden camera investigation (Marketplace) · CBC News · 20:46
- How to Speed up a Python Program 114,000 times. · InfoQ · 59:11
- "Games as a service" is fraud. · Accursed Farms · 1:15:54
- Design Microservice Architectures the Right Way · InfoQ · 48:29
- Mike Monteiro: F*ck You, Pay Me · CreativeMornings HQ · 37:53
- Crockford on JavaScript - Volume 1: The Early Years · YUI Library · 1:42:08
- Homemade Transistor Demonstration · Jeri Ellsworth · 3:10
- Steve Jobs Content vs Process · Bo Manton · 2:37
- How Python was Shaped by leaky Internals, Armin Ronacher, Flask framework · Видео с мероприятий {speach! · 49:55
- CppCon 2015: Andrei Alexandrescu “std::allocator...” · CppCon · 1:12:27
- Lexical Scanning in Go - Rob Pike · GoogleFOSSSydney · 51:17
- Why Isn't Functional Programming the Norm? – Richard Feldman · Metosin · 46:09
- Overwatch Gameplay Architecture and Netcode · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:04:03
- Maybe Not - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:03:28
- Conway's Game Of Life in APL · Dyalog · 7:47
- Lecture 1A | MIT 6.001 Structure and Interpretation, 1986 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 1:12:55