Psp collections: views and more by Paul Phillips

Channel:AI Council · Length:1:28:58 · Published:2014-02-06 · Views:11458

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Paul Phillips, a major Scala compiler contributor, gives a long talk on Scala collections and views, using it to critique Scala's design and direction.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in Scala debates as an insider's critique that persuaded many the language's problems were deep.

Then I watched this Paul Phillips talk, which convinced me that the problems were deep, not superficial — HN, 2018

Programming language design · Functional programming · Compilers, interpreters & program analysis

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] [Applause] [Applause] [Music] hi I am as it says up there Paul Phillips and I'm going to talk to you about uh scholar Collections and about how I might write scholar collections differently well did a little bit um some of the information has already been overtaken by events because I don't know how much longer I can write Scala without jumping off of something so uh let's take a look when I'm working on a problem I never think about beauty you've all seen this quote because there's only like 10 quotes that are relevant to programming and they just get recycled over and over when I'm working on a problem I never think about beauty I only think about how to solve the problem but when I finished if the solution is not beautiful I know that it is wrong to a first approximation I think this is a fantastic quote because when something that you there's an intuitive feel that you develop after a while of programming uh you just know you're going the wrong way um some people get that intuitive feel faster than others uh this is I think the point at which you should know that the solution is not beautiful this ungodly thing that you're you're looking at which is a little difficult to read uh in the red this is this is a single boilerplate trait

On Hacker News

Going by Paul Phillips's (largest contributor to the scala compiler) YouTube rant, [VIDEO] , nobody ever gets over the cliffs. His rant is great, for more than just scala. — bjwbell, 2015-09
> Or use a better language ;-). E.g. in Scala You might want to watch Paul Phillips' recent talk: [VIDEO] You will probably start changing your mind about whether Scala is a "better" language. Especially on the collections side. > to get all the benefits without the drawbacks of Java style subtyping. Actually, the Scala collections have the exact same problems caused by subtyping that Java does (… — laureny, 2014-02
I am curious to what extent Paul Phillips lecture [ [VIDEO] ] is just a rant or in-depth Scala criticism. If he's right then seems that we should not expect bright future for Scala. I am wondering what Scala experts would say (I don't know Scala sufficiently to trust my judgment)? — piokoch, 2015-11
Wow. Just starting to watch, but my first thought is: thank goodness he got to give this talk when he did; otherwise he might have exploded. The link that works for me on a desktop browser: [VIDEO] — wpietri, 2015-09
Could you (and perhaps others) say more about this? I was excited to read that key goals were simplification, clarification, and consolidation. But my exact worry is that they didn't go far enough. I liked the idea of Scala and took Odersky's course. But I built a few things in it and it was never not frustrating. What Bruce Eckels said resonates with me: "I’ve come to view Scala as a landscape o… — wpietri, 2018-04

Related videos