Elon Musk's "Loop" - It's bad, folks

Channel:donoteat01 · Length:40:05 · Published:2019-01-19 · Views:920959

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A long, sarcastic critique of Elon Musk's Loop tunnel transit idea and related Boring Company and Hyperloop claims. It leans on transit-planning arguments about capacity and throughput.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to rebuttal when Musk's transportation proposals come up, though it is mostly cited by skeptics.

he gives some realistic criticism if you can get past the jokes — HN, 2020

Tech industry & business models · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

okay I'm finally finished with my autonomous cars episode now to just check the news before I hit the render button and take a big sip of coffee so the loop is pretty much the stupidest idea I've ever personally seen go to the proof of concept stage but you know second only to the Hyperloop so here's how it's supposed to work Elon Musk's boring company will dig tunnels under major cities and you'll be able to take your car through those tunnels at high speed the cars will be guided by little wheels on the front with brace into a guide way in the tunnel it's the same system as a guided bus but it's faster there will be a little elevator at each end which can bring your car up and down from the tunnel system this will once and for all fixed traffic ok right there will be no chance of overcrowding in the system because the boring company can just build more tunnels they can do this because they will make tunneling much cheaper by means of improved tunnel boring machine technology Elon says he wants to go 20 or 30 layers down with the tunnels sure ok Elon expects to move 4000 cars per hour at a speed of a hundred and 50 miles per hour through each - some of these cars will be pods which will carry up to 16 people thereby making it mass transit

On Hacker News

first time I heard that term was in donoteat01's video on the loop[0], haven't got around to reading that post till now though (thanks for the reminder) [0] Elon Musk's "Loop" - It's bad, folks [VIDEO] — disk0, 2020-08
I know it's a big ask to send you a 40 min youtube video, but grab some popcorn and enjoy: [VIDEO] TL;DW No. Tunnels are hard to rapidly dig (esp. in the US where property rights exist underground), they require safety elements like proper ventilation, and they are still subject to congestion at the destination exits. — littlelady, 2023-10
That's what [VIDEO] focuses on primarily. Increased capacity is completely useless if you can't get cars in and out. and you can't. — Avshalom, 2021-08
[VIDEO] I like this video too. This guy seems to be an urban planner or civil engineer, and he gives some realistic criticism if you can get past the jokes (which are also good) — postingpals, 2020-11
It's been stated elsewhere in this thread, but there really are a lot of practical, well-understood engineering issues with Elon's proposals that he refuses to admit or deal with. Here's a somewhat humorous review of his claims / what's wrong with them and how they stack up to actual civil engineering projects: [VIDEO] — atharris, 2020-10

Related videos