What If Alien Life Were Silicon-Based?

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:21:56 · Published:2023-01-26 · Views:3764135

Watch on YouTube

Summary

PBS Space Time considers whether life could be based on silicon instead of carbon, comparing the two elements' chemistry and why silicon is the most plausible alternative.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a solid, informative treatment of silicon-based life and the chemical limits on alien biochemistry.

PBS Space Time has a very good & informative episode covering this. — HN, 2025

Cosmology & astrophysics · Chemistry · Biology & biotechnology

Subtitles (excerpt)

Thank you to brilliant.org for supporting PBS. Life as we know it is carbon-based, but does it have to be that way? There is another element on the periodic table that shares some of the key properties of carbon but is far more abundant on most planets. I’m talking about silicon. So could there silicon-based life out there? All of the chemical machinery of life - all biochemistry - is based around the carboan atom. At least as far as we know. If we want to understand the possible diversity and abundance of life in the universe, we need to ask whether this is the only option Perhaps the most popular alternative - at least in science fiction - is silicon-based life. We have the xenomorphs of the Alien series to the giant space worm in Star Wars and many, many others. So why are scifi writers so into silicon-based life? Because it really is the most promising non-carbon prospect due to its chemical similarity. It’s also more abundant on Earth than carbon. So, can life be based on silicon? And if so, why aren’t we silicon-based? When we say life is carbon-based, we don’t just mean that life uses carbon a lot - we mean that literally every aspect of the molecular machinery that makes up life is

On Hacker News

PBS Space Time has a very good & informative episode covering this. I'll try to dig it up. Most elements are missing some key properties that carbon has. Silicon is the next most-likely element, but it's still missing out on a few properties that carbon has. Here: [LINK] Or on YouTube: [VIDEO] — ziddoap, 2025-01
PBS Space Time: What If Alien Life Were Silicon-Based? [VIDEO] There are very few atoms that allow for the complex scaffolding for shapes. Many atoms are too large (and thus bond too weakly). Silicon is interesting, but it has some difficulties. [LINK] > Silicon–oxygen single bonds are longer (1.6 vs 1.4 Å) but stronger (452 vs. about 360 kJ mol−1) than carbon–oxygen single bonds. It is much easi… — shagie, 2024-05
It is a fun thought, but chemistry is not infinitely complex. Much like the Fermi paradox, once you start applying real world qualifiers on chemistry of complex life the search space becomes quite small. [VIDEO] Life inside of stars does enable different options. — willis936, 2023-02

Related videos