Epic v Apple: Judgment Day - Who Won? Who Lost? ...and Why? (VL538)
Channel:Hoeg Law · Length:2:26:21 · Published:2021-09-11 · Views:28547
Summary
Hoeg Law's Virtual Legality walks through the 185-page Epic v. Apple decision, covering antitrust law, relevant markets, anti-steering and who actually won. It runs well over two hours and corrects common media misreadings.
Why HN recommends it
Strongly recommended as the best explanation of the ruling, in more depth and with more accuracy than press coverage.
I'd suggest watching the excellent video by Hoeg Law. — HN, 2021
Tech industry & business models · Law, policing & justice
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] hello and welcome to another episode of virtual legality i'm your host richard hogue managing member of the hoglaw business law firm of northfield michigan and it's the one you've all been waiting for folks yes it's the trial court's decision in epic versus apple but before we talk about it let's take a trip in the wayback machine to talk to a pretty smart fellow from a few months ago i think the judge rightfully thinks that epic's theory goes too far i think they are unlikely to give them a win on the monopoly question as i've mentioned earlier in the series if this access is monopolistic then you've got all sorts of problems with every walled garden on earth i think that she is likely to deny them that but who knows and then i think that she might just want to give epic a little bit of a win because of what she has seen from apple and what epic has been able to prove about how apple interacts with its developers and say that those anti-steering rules have to be modified have to go probably with apple and epic sitting at the table for how that looks so if you've been in virtual legality with us since at least the making of that video then you're probably pretty familiar with what the decision actually wound up being if you
On Hacker News
I'd suggest watching the excellent video by Hoeg Law. He has followed the case from the outset and goes through the ruling in intricate detail. Even within the first few minutes he starts noting how much of the media coverage is wrong or overstated. [VIDEO] — simondotau, 2021-09
There's an excellent overview of the US Federal court's 180 page decision on Youtube, but it's rather long. The diction is good, so it's still understandable when set to run at a faster speed. The first 15 minutes is a summary and the balance of the video is a more detailed look. [VIDEO] TL;DW, the judge makes it clear that Apple can still charge a cut even if developers use someone else's paymen… — GeekyBear, 2022-02
Absolutely correct. The Verge and other media reporters continues to omit this important note from the ruling itself from [0]: Under all models, Apple would be entitled to a commission or licensing fee, even if IAP was optional [0] (p68) Seems like The Verge loves to spin their way into misinformation since they know that the majority of readers won't read the ruling text at all. For those that d… — rvz, 2021-11
If you're willing to wade through a very long YouTube video, HoagLaw offers a two and a half hour summary of the 185 page judgement: [VIDEO] — GeekyBear, 2021-09
Precisely. As I and many others already highlighted it is not over yet and they are both likely going to appeal this. The media outright jumped into conclusions with their headlines and caused this hype of misinformation to spread very quickly and now we have to cut thought it and correct the wrongs they reported. I also recommend those interested to watch the first 4 minutes of the Hoeg Law vide… — rvz, 2021-09
Related videos
- Avie Tevanian: CMU math whiz goes from Mach to NeXT to Apple Software Chief | Oral History Part 1 · Computer History Museum · 2:31:38
- Steve Jobs President & CEO, NeXT Computer Corp and Apple. MIT Sloan Distinguished Speaker Series · MIT Video Productions · 1:12:53
- [60 fps] The Flying Train, Germany, 1902 · Denis Shiryaev · 3:47
- The Smartphone CPU Review You NEED to Watch! · Geekerwan · 26:13
- [4k, 60 fps] San Francisco, a Trip down Market Street, April 14, 1906 · Denis Shiryaev · 14:22
- Windows "SUCKS": How I'd Fix it by a retired Microsoft Windows engineer · Dave's Garage · 16:09
- Oral History of Dave Cutler Part 1 · Computer History Museum · 1:44:36
- VCF East: Xerox Star vs. Apple Lisa · Vintage Computer Federation · 42:38
- Mojo Lang - Tomorrow's High Performance Python? (with Chris Lattner) · Developer Voices · 1:24:38
- How I Upgraded My iPhone Memory 800% - in Shenzhen, China · Strange Parts · 31:01
- [CVPR'21 WAD] Keynote - Andrej Karpathy, Tesla · WAD at CVPR · 31:31
- Starbase Tour with Elon Musk [PART 1 // Summer 2021] · Everyday Astronaut · 53:17
- Don't Talk to the Police · Regent University School of Law · 46:38
- YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is. · Tom Scott · 42:29
- Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:00:56
- Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism · AmericanRhetoric.com · 7:21