Stop Signs Suck and We Should Get Rid of Them
Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:6:04 · Published:2020-01-13 · Views:907547
Summary
Not Just Bikes argues that stop signs are a poor traffic control, drawing on Dutch practice and the Idaho stop to show intersections can be safer without them, especially for cyclists.
Why HN recommends it
Cited in threads about cyclist safety and traffic law as an explanation of why removing stop signs can improve safety.
Here is a great video about life without stop signs in the Netherlands — HN, 2022
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
One thing I really don’t miss about Canada is stop signs. Putting stop signs everywhere is a sign of failure; it’s the road design equivalent of, “We’ve tried nothing, and we’re all out of ideas.” Nobody completely stops at stop signs: not cyclists, not drivers. This guy doesn’t even bother to slow down. Stop signs are notoriously inefficient. After a string of police ticketing, cyclists in San Francisco staged a protest where every cyclist came to a complete stop at this stop sign. The queue of bicycles and cars stretched several blocks down the street. But stop signs aren’t just inconvenient for cyclists; they’re actually less safe. Many cities allow cyclists to yield at stop signs, and studies have been published about the results. This study found 14% fewer crashes. And this one found that when crashes do happen, they result in less serious injuries. So, why does this happen? Well, just like people walking, people on bicycles are vulnerable road users. Which is the problem when you take laws for cars and try to apply them to bicycles. For example, bicycles are extremely slow to get going from a complete stop. Look at how long I’m in this intersection if I yield at the stop sign: less than two and a half seconds.
On Hacker News
If there's that much traffic, a four way stop will be even worse than a roundabout. You'll need a turbo roundabout, traffic lights or grade separated intersections in that case. Four way stops are one of the dumbest inventions of man kind that are way over used in North America. Everyone has to stop all the time and it leads to scary situations at 2 way stops because people don't expect those any… — xputer, 2022-08
Everybody here is discussing the car and the cyclist, but I don't see anybody considering the possibility that the intersection design is unsafe. That there is a stop sign is a pretty bad signal in itself, Not Just Bikes made a video explaining this: [VIDEO] — ruuda, 2024-02
> Not saying its a bad idea, but I'm still struggling to see the full logic of it. If you don't have to stop at an intersection, you get through the intersection much faster and are therefore in less danger. This is true for all vehicles but especially true of bicycles, which don't always accelerate as fast. Here's a video demonstration [VIDEO] — aqme28, 2022-04
It's counter-intuitive, but the data [0][1] is quite clear that laws like these significantly improve safety for bicyclists. I found this video [2] useful in understanding what might be going on. [0] [LINK] ("All reported injury crashes involving bicycles at stop sign controlled intersections dropped 23% in the 30 months after adopting the Safety Stop compared to 30 months prior to adoption") [1]… — rsanek, 2022-04
No, I think stop signs are a horrible design flaw that we have to live with, and rolling stops are the least bad way to work around that urban design flaw. It is asinine to force arbitrary stops at random intersections that have no time-of-day or traffic sensitivity (i.e. am I alone on the roads at 2AM, or are children walking to school at 8AM). Or to put them at intersections with clear cross vi… — medvezhenok, 2024-09
Related videos
- Spec-ulation Keynote - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:16:13
- The Wrong Way to Set Speed Limits [ST06] · Not Just Bikes · 11:08
- The Lively & Liveable Neighbourhoods that are Illegal in Most of North America · Not Just Bikes · 7:18
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02
- The Best Country in the World for Drivers · Not Just Bikes · 15:48
- Why We Won't Raise Our Kids in Suburbia · Not Just Bikes · 12:13
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- Why Louisiana Stays Poor · Together Louisiana · 15:25
- How Self-Driving Cars will Destroy Cities (and what to do about it) · Not Just Bikes · 54:37
- Why American Cities Are Broke - The Growth Ponzi Scheme [ST03] · Not Just Bikes · 9:39
- Cities Aren't Loud: Cars Are Loud · Not Just Bikes · 17:08
- Why Canadians Can't Bike in the Winter (but Finnish people can) · Not Just Bikes · 15:13
- How the Dutch got their cycle paths · BicycleDutch · 6:29
- Why Japan Looks the Way it Does: Zoning · Life Where I'm From · 14:34
- Why Grocery Shopping is Better in Amsterdam · Not Just Bikes · 3:46
- What can Seattle learn from Dutch street design? · UniversityGreenways · 1:05:18