Debate Noam Chomsky & Michel Foucault - On human nature [Subtitled]

Channel:withDefiance · Length:1:10:03 · Published:2013-03-13 · Views:2680912

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The full 1971 Dutch television debate between Noam Chomsky and Michel Foucault on human nature, with subtitles. They discuss creativity, knowledge, power and politics.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a famous, revealing clash between two thinkers, though some note they largely talk past each other.

For anyone who hasn't watched the actual, full video of the debate, you should do so. — HN, 2015

Politics & history (other) · Consciousness & cognition · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

In the 17th century, when Galilei discovered that the earth turned around the sun instead of the other way around, many people were in a state of great shock. They had thus far believed that humans were at the center of the cosmos and around this idea they had built their whole belief system. Suddenly, this did not seem to be the case anymore. Foucault's theory can be clarified by pointing out that, in relation to culture, he takes a sort of Galilei-type standpoint. Since the time of Galilei, people have thought that when it came to culture and society, humans do were at the center. After all, it is they who created these. Foucault denies this. It is not the subject that counts to culture he argues, but the structure, the universal. Something that is in itself already understandable if one realizes that the rules according to which mankind behaves for the largest part were already invented long before one was born. And the name of the inventor remains completely unknown to us. One can compare Foucault to Galilei, but from another perspective, one can also compare Chomsky to Galilei because his work in the science of language -- linguistics -- has had a great revolutionary influence over the whole world.

On Hacker News

1. Languages are used for much, much more than communication, and there is good reason to think that capacity didn't evolve for communication, but rather for metacognitive problem solving. 2. The idea that Tolkein --one of the most reknowned writers in our entire canon-- did something isn't relevant to the philosophical discussion of creativity and its obvious bounds. Even Tolkein was just painti… — bbor, 2026-07
For anyone who hasn't watched the actual, full video of the debate, you should do so. Watching them argue in two languages at the same time is super fun. [VIDEO] Okay, here's what the video is saying, in slightly-longer form. The exchange in the video is basically Chomsky saying "human nature" and Foucault laughing. This gets at the heart of the hour-long debate: do humans have some sort of natur… — steveklabnik, 2015-04
For anyone who hasn't seen it yet, here's an interesting debate between Foucault and Chomsky: [1] Unfortunately, they're mostly speaking past each other, but it's still worth watching. [1] - [VIDEO] — pmoriarty, 2019-10
I think he is not interested in epistemology. But I always find discussions on the origins or human knowledge just as fascinating as you. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. It sounds like you may have already been exposed to it given the content of your arguments, but there is a very enjoyable debate/discussion between Foucault and Chomsky on the acquisitions of human knowledge and human nature [1… — marnett, 2018-03
really wierd, most of my exposure to foucault is indirect. this debate with chomsky on human nature is interesting [VIDEO] — f00_, 2017-09

Related videos