The problems with Helion Energy - a response to Real Engineering
Channel:Improbable Matter · Length:7:16 · Published:2023-01-19 · Views:913854
Summary
A short, humorous critique of Helion Energy's fusion approach, framed as a response to a Real Engineering video. It covers low reactivity, neutron production, bremsstrahlung losses and diagnostics.
Why HN recommends it
HN cites it as a skeptical rebuttal to Helion's promises, usually in threads on fusion power and Helion's Microsoft deal.
check out this good summary of all the issues with their approach and promise — HN, 2023
Fundamental physics · Nuclear power & fusion
Subtitles (excerpt)
People have been asking me to look at the private company Helion Energy ever since it was profiled by a YouTube channel called Real Engineering. I'm not sure whether I can convince anyone of anything, since I only have a bunch of boring charts and no fancy 3D graphics, so there we go. Besides, I already discussed many of the challenges in my technical "How Fusion Works" series, so I will pull some clips out of there. In that video, Real Engineering claimed that Helion Energy's Trenta machine is, quote: "a closely guarded secret for years", end quote, even though the company have put up results on their own YouTube channel and reported them to the public agencies that they were originally funded by. Helion is reportedly using the Field Reversed Configuration or FRC approach to fusion. FRC machines have been built extensively since the 1960s, so this is absolutely nothing new even though CEO David Kirtley said, quote: "it's a real unique version of fusion fuel that helion and very few others do", end quote. The first challenge for Helion is that they plan on using the Deuterium-Helium3 reaction. This is a much less reactive fuel mix than Deuterium-Tritium, which is the reaction in most other
On Hacker News
There are probably a lot of optimizations in the silicone and software to find. It's not necessarily obvious what corners can get cut or where, the tradeoffs of tapping out new chips is worth it. Yet Another Matrix Multiplication Chip is not going to set the world on fire. Nvidia has that market pretty well captured. But perhaps it turns out that subnets can be trained independently or swapped wi… — PBnFlash, 2024-02
I just realized it's THAT Helion. Their fusion experiments are not without controversy. Here's a video on explaining how it works: [LINK] And here's a video explaining what's wrong with the scheme: [VIDEO] But the TLDW version is that environment required for fusing He3 with deuterium also leads to deuterium fusing with itself, a reaction that creates neutron radiation that irradiates its environ… — torginus, 2023-11
[VIDEO] Be careful with real engineering. Many speculate he's doing paid content between this and spinlaunch. — deelowe, 2023-08
You can be optimistic when you’re just making an app to rent your room out or to find a dog walker. You can hustle and sell useless SaaS services long enough to get acquired for no real reason except managerial power plays in large companies. In the world of software you can kinda make almost any idea work with sweat and political maneuvering. You can literally see that they’re trying to play the… — ramraj07, 2023-05
Yeah me too, to layman that looked really promising, but then I watch this[0] video, and now I do not know what to belive. [0]: [VIDEO] — born-jre, 2023-01
Related videos
- MIT's Pathway to Fusion Energy (IAP 2017) - Zach Hartwig · MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center · 1:11:39
- Breakthrough in Nuclear Fusion? - Prof. Dennis Whyte · MIT Club of Northern California · 1:38:48
- I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate · AlphaPhoenix · 22:48
- How close is nuclear fusion power? · Sabine Hossenfelder · 12:49
- The Speed of Light is NOT About Light · PBS Space Time · 12:46
- Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light · Veritasium · 19:05
- Richard Feynman - The.Character of Physical Law - Part 1 The Law of Gravitation (full version) · Tinkerin' Thinkers · 56:04
- HD Feynman: FUN TO IMAGINE complete (with optional Chinese subtitles) · Christopher Sykes · 1:06:49
- A new way to visualize General Relativity · ScienceClic English · 11:33
- Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of the Universe - with David Tong · The Royal Institution · 1:00:17
- The Physics and Philosophy of Time - with Carlo Rovelli · The Royal Institution · 54:54
- How Special Relativity Makes Magnets Work · Veritasium · 4:19
- The Biggest Ideas in the Universe: Introduction · Sean Carroll · 6:33
- The Biggest Misconception About Electricity · Veritasium · 14:48
- Watch electricity hit a fork in the road at half a billion frames per second · AlphaPhoenix · 26:29
- Feynman: Magnets (and Why?) FUN TO IMAGINE 4/ higher quality version! · Christopher Sykes · 7:34