Self and Self: Whys and Wherefores

Channel:Stanford · Length:1:10:10 · Published:2010-01-23 · Views:29905

Watch on YouTube

Summary

David Ungar of IBM Research reflects at Stanford on the Self language project and argues the real legacy of ideas is the people. He covers its history, philosophy, successes and failures.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as the best account of what Self made possible and what its team went on to do.

explains the history, philosophy, successes, and failures of the Self project — HN, 2022

Programming language design · Compilers, interpreters & program analysis

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] Stanford University Welcome to the second uh edition of second volume or whatever of 380 all quarter 2009 2010 uh a little bit of administrivia I seem to have confused some of you about how the class actually works it's a uh per lecture assignment not at the end of the time summarize the whole thing per lecture convinces that you paid attention understood what was going on and 10 of those and you get your unit um now we've gotten through that it is all web- based um today's speak speaker David uner wrote four thesis probably a mistake uh they're all great ideas all great implementation packaged it into one thing and as a result nobody knew KN nobody knew what to do with what he'd done um so today's talk is about how to manage a career and how to manage ideas when you do too much which is a problem uh many of you will discover that you've got too many good things to put into a thesis and that's actually a problem you need to go a little lower but it is still possible to succeed if you make this mistake and today's speaker will tell us how well thank you thanks let me just start by checking we've got sound out of the computer uh yes we do excellent okay good we may need that may need to be a little

On Hacker News

To get a feeling for the Self language and what was (is) possible, you should (if you can, of course) take the time to watch the video: [VIDEO] It contains a few gems, and is really worthwhile watching. (Disclaimer, I think Dave Ungar has done tremendous things for PLDI; interested people should definitely check out his UC-Berkeley PhD thesis of 1986, easily one of the best I have ever seen...) — sb, 2010-12
David Unger gave a great talk recently on this: [VIDEO] (recorded at Stanford, but it's a reprise of his acceptance speech on receiving the Dahl-Nygaard award from memory) He has a role-call at the end of what the people involved in the self project went on to do afterwards, and it's staggering: some of the engineers of the original Google architecture, what became Hotspot as you say, Lars Bak (o… — mark_h, 2010-07
What was really interesting about Self was its optimizability - they were able to implement a Smalltalk on Self that was much faster than the contemporary Smalltalk systems. The impression I got from poking around at Self was that there was a class/inheritance system informally approximated in the prototypical relations of the objects and traits, but that doesn't mean you can't formally define on… — rileyphone, 2022-05
[0] is Self and Self: Whys and Wherefores < [VIDEO] > > And at the time, we thought it was impossible to make this language run efficiently, because it did all these things that were more abstract than languages of the time ... — hayley-patton, 2025-10
Self and Self: Whys and Wherefores (September 30, 2009) David Unger, from IBM Research, discusses how his experience in computer science has led him to the conclusion that even if your ideas succeed, the real legacy is the people. [VIDEO] — DonHopkins, 2022-11

Related videos