Milton Friedman - Illegal Immigration - PT 1

Channel:LibertyPen · Length:5:27 · Published:2009-12-11 · Views:621943

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of economist Milton Friedman discussing the dynamics of illegal immigration and its relationship with the welfare state. It is part one of two.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a reference for Friedman's argument that generous welfare and open immigration are in tension.

Milton Friedman discussed this fundamental contention between welfare and free immigration — HN, 2014

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Labor, work & inequality · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] I have always been amused by a kind of a paradox suppose you go around and ask people the United States as you know before 1914 had completely free immigration anybody could get on a boat and come to these Shores and if he landed on Ellis Island he was an immigrant was that a good thing or a bad thing you will find hardly a soul who will say it was a bad thing almost everybody will say it was a good thing but then I suppose I say to the same people but now what about today do you think we should have free immigration oh no they'll say we couldn't Poss possibly have free immigration today why that would that would flood us with immigrants from India and God knows where we'd be driven down to a a bare subsistence level what's the difference how can people be so inconsistent why is it that free immigration was a good thing before 1914 and free immigration is a bad thing today well there's a sense in which that answer is right there's a sense in which free immigration in the same sense as we had it before in 1914 is not possible today why not because it is one thing to have free immigration to jobs it is another thing to have free immigration to welfare and you cannot have both if you have a welfare state if

On Hacker News

It's fair to bemoan the general decline of your society with the desire to better your personal lot through immigrating. It's likely that they don't dislike foreigners but they do dislike being forced to subsidise them via taxes. It's a side effect of the welfare state. Milton Friedmen convers it pretty well in [VIDEO] . It's an old problem :/ — abz10, 2016-09
One potential side effect of a minimum income is to make the U.S. (or any country implementing it), even more immigrant hostile. These programs usually only consider the effects in a vacuum, not with respect to much larger population that wants to get in. Either immigration needs to be restricted, or you have a "lower" non citizen class that doesn't get these benefits from the beginning (ironical… — tolmasky, 2014-12
Some interesting thoughts on immigration from economist Milton Friedman ( [VIDEO] ): I’ve always been amused by a kind of a paradox. Suppose you go around and ask people: ‘The United States before 1914, as you know, had completely free immigration. Anybody could get in a boat and come to these shores and if landed at Ellis Island he was an immigrant. Was that a good thing or a bad thing? You will… — olalonde, 2011-04

Related videos