The Loudness War

Channel:Matt Mayfield Music · Length:1:53 · Published:2006-10-07 · Views:2671826

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A two-minute demonstration of the loudness war, showing how heavy dynamic range compression in CD mastering makes music louder while degrading sound quality. It uses audio examples so you can hear the distortion.

Why HN recommends it

HN keeps linking it as the shortest clear explanation of over-compression and brickwalled mastering.

this video which gave a very succinct answer to my question — HN, 2016

Information theory & signal processing · Audio & video engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

this is how the so-called loudness war is damaging the sound quality of modern CDs first I'll play an example of a track from 1989 notice the clarity and punch of the [Music] drums since the two drum hits are already maximum volume if we want the track louder on the recording we have to take the quieter bits and turn them up if this track had been released in 2006 someone would probably have insisted that it' be this [Music] [Laughter] loud now it sounds much louder and in the short term louder can seem better but you own the volume knob not the record producer so you adjust your volume to find your preferred level here we have the same volume as the original unfortunately the the loudness treatment permanently changes the sound do you notice what's missing the red sections Mark where the punch and Clarity would have been let's hear what that maximized track sounds like at regular listening [Music] volume wimpy loud sound all the punch of the drums is gone along with much of the feel of the music that comes from some parts being louder than others when there's no quiet there can be no loud the original makes you turn up your volume and when you do it sounds [Music] great

On Hacker News

Your post led me down the rabbit hole of over-compression, not for the first time, and I ended up at this video which gave a very succinct answer to my question of: "Okay, I realize that music is getting compressed, but what are we losing?" [VIDEO] Via a nice article with analysis: [LINK] — morsch, 2016-05
The same reason why music on the radio is so dang loud– excessive compression. See: The Loudness War (just 1:54 mins long): [VIDEO] — visakanv, 2015-04
I think one of the reasons that those people who prefer vinyl over digital do so, is that the recordings on vinyl are mastered with different qualities in mind than their digital counterparts. There's a YouTube video floating around called The Loudness War ( [VIDEO] ) that describes what I'm talking about. I distinctly remember albums on audio CDs sounding better to me (great clarity, vibrancy, e… — 9oliYQjP, 2009-04
And now we have the Loudness War where the songs are so highly compressed that there is no dynamic range. Because of this, I have to reduce the volume so it isn't painful to listen to. And this makes what should have been a live recording with interesting sound into background noise. Example: [VIDEO] If you want a recent-ish album to listen to that has good sound, try Daft Punk's Random Access Me… — chiph, 2025-11
”The same thoughtless disregard for basic music fundamentals that plagued the preliminary edits ended up on the final OST.” As a musician and music-lover, seeing how they brickwalled [1][2] Mick’s tracks in the screenshots only serves to add to the heartbreak of his entire saga. [1] Loudness War [LINK] [2] The Loudness War [VIDEO] — Arjuna, 2022-11

Related videos