USENIX ATC '21/OSDI '21 Joint Keynote Address-It's Time for Operating Systems to Rediscover Hardware

Channel:USENIX · Length:1:06:19 · Published:2021-08-06 · Views:46453

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Timothy Roscoe of ETH Zurich delivers the joint USENIX ATC/OSDI 2021 keynote arguing that operating systems must reckon with modern hardware, which is a heterogeneous collection of processors, firmware and coprocessors rather than a simple machine. It shows how much runs below and beside Linux.

Why HN recommends it

Repeatedly recommended as a revelatory talk on how little control the main OS has over modern SoCs and PCs.

There's this great USENIX talk by Timothy Roscoe [1] — HN, 2022

Operating systems & kernels · Computer architecture & CPUs

Subtitles (excerpt)

well thank you hello and uh thank you very much for inviting me to give a keynote two keynotes i guess simultaneously at osdi and atc i feel very honoured these are also two conferences that i love i feel very home at home here these are my kinds of conferences and so i'm very grateful to be here when i was asked to give a keynote um i tried to think about how to give a good keynote what kinds of keynote would be appropriate for a pair of usenix conferences like this and i typed a usenix keynote into internet search engines and the top five hits were all basically james mickens uh which was a bit discouraging for me because i cannot possibly match james's uh wit er edition and insight in his keynotes so i will do the best i can so having been failed by the internet i tried to remember the kind of keynotes i'd seen in the past and to sort of look at what sort of things might make sense what sort of models there were for how to give a good keynote and seemed to be a number uh that i remember one of which is um i could sort of spend 45 minutes being smug about my past research and telling you about it uh i don't really feel terribly smug about my research for reasons that will probably become clear uh

On Hacker News

This isn’t my space to opine on, but I found this talk both riveting and compelling: [VIDEO] In a nutshell, the useful fiction of computer-as-Von-Neumann-meaning doesn’t adequately reflect the reality of modern hardware. Not only does the CPU itself not fit that model (with things like speculative execution, sophisticated power and load management…), but the system as a whole is increasingly an a… — jcgl, 2026-02
There's this great USENIX talk by Timothy Roscoe [1], which is part of the Enzian Team at ETH Zürich. It's about the dominant unholistic approach to modern operating system design, which is reflected in the vast number of independent, proprietary, under-documented RTOSes running in tandem on a single system, and eventually leading to uninspiring and lackluster OS research (e.g. Linux monoculture)… — dist1ll, 2022-11
I know that I recommended it in the talk, but I highly recommend Timothy Roscoe's OSDI keynote[0] -- and may also be worth catching the Twitter Space we did a few weeks ago discussing it.[1] [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — bcantrill, 2021-10
I'd say the computer architecture can vary _greatly_ and there are a bunch of cores in modern SOC's that kind of break the assumption of how a computer works. I recently listened to this: [VIDEO] Cache coherence, accelerators, various takes on pipelining, ISA extensions. There are many many things that change all the time. Not even touching the SW glue stuff that changes. I don't know the history… — RealityVoid, 2024-08
Plenty of good links here already. I'll just add that booting is enormously complex, and starts well before any of the dozen comments so far. I skimmed many of them (not all) and they all tell pretty much the same story whether on real hardware or virtual. But modern real hardware first boots a Management Engine (or BMC, or T2, or similar), which prepares things and starts subsystems like hardwar… — jiveturkey, 2023-03

Related videos