Are Black Holes Actually Fuzzballs?

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:16:28 · Published:2021-11-17 · Views:1319986

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A PBS Space Time episode on fuzzballs, the string-theory proposal for black holes that replaces the singularity with a tangle of strings. It explains why black holes seem to both have to exist and break known physics.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an accessible pointer when threads discuss black hole models that avoid singularities.

PBS space time goes into a few of them — HN, 2023

Quantum physics · Cosmology & astrophysics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Thank you to Brilliant for supporting PBS. Black holes are a paradox. They are paradoxical because they simultaneously must exist but can’t, and so they break physics as we know it. But many physicists will tell you that the best way to fix broken physics is with string. String theory, in fact. And in the black holes of string theory - fuzzballs - are perhaps even weirder than the regular type Einstein’s general theory of relativity tells us that if the density of matter is sufficiently ridiculous, ultimate gravitational collapse is inevitable. The matter should contract to a single point of infinite density - the singularity - which is surrounded by a surface from which even light can’t escape - the event horizon. And we see these black holes - or at least their incontrovertible evidence - in many places out there in the universe. But black holes are also impossible. At the central singularity, the known laws of physics break down - general relativity comes into irreconcilable conflict with quantum mechanics. There’s our first paradox. And at the event horizon another paradox arises. On the one hand, general relativity insists that no information from the matter that fell into a black hole should be observable on

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] There are a number of theories on black holes not being singularities. PBS space time goes into a few of them — treeman79, 2023-05
Black holes would be different if string theory is right. There would be no singularity, for instance, and no interior. String theory black holes (which are called fuzzballs) would emit slightly different gravitational waves when they merge. We should have sensitive enough gravitation wave detecters in the not too distant future to check this. There was a PBS Space Time episode on fuzzballs last … — tzs, 2022-04
@PBSSpaceTime videos: "Where Is The Center of The Universe?" (2022) [LINK] "Could The Universe Be Inside A Black Hole?" (2022) [LINK] "The Holographic Universe Explained" (2019) [LINK] "Are Black Holes Actually Fuzzballs?" (2022) [VIDEO] — westurner, 2022-03

Related videos