Brave New World vs Nineteen Eighty-Four featuring Adam Gopnik and Will Self

Channel:Intelligence Squared · Length:1:35:44 · Published:2018-02-12 · Views:728714

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An Intelligence Squared debate in which Will Self argues for Brave New World and Adam Gopnik for Nineteen Eighty-Four as the better dystopian warning. It includes acted excerpts and is chaired by Jonathan Freedland.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a good long debate for the recurring question of whether Orwell or Huxley was right.

this debate between will self and adam gopnik on 'brave new world' vs '1984' is really good if anybody has 1.5 hours to indulge. — HN, 2022

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Literature & writing craft · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Thank You Hana thanks to all of you for coming my name is Jonathan friedland I'm going to be guiding the proceedings this evening and often you know you have these cultural combat evenings where the debate is of course enlightening and fascinating but rarely can it claim to be urgently topical and yet somehow with two novels one written in 1931 and one written in between 1948 1949 you nevertheless have two works that speak to us in our own time with great urgency and topicality we of course are going to leave proceedings tonight knowing which one does that more than the other one but that is the subject before so two dominant novels of the 20th century discussed and debated and advocated by two of the leading public intellectuals of our 21st century so it's going to be a hugely stimulating evening the other thing about cultural combat events is that they often have a different quality from the debates that intelligent squared hosts on this stage those of course are about the current affairs questions of our time the big political questions whereas the cultural debate can be at a more serene pace and yet here we have two novels which speak absolutely of the questions that ordinarily we might

On Hacker News

I don't know if Brave New World or 1984 was right. You will enjoy this debate about that exact question: [VIDEO] Fantastic oratory, excerpts acted out by famous actors, intriguing ideas. Marvelous production. — stickfigure, 2018-10
yes! thank you. huxley was right about a scary number of things... this debate between will self and adam gopnik on 'brave new world' vs '1984' is really good if anybody has 1.5 hours to indulge. [VIDEO] just grabbed 'amusing ourselves to death' from libby, thanks for the recommendation! — LesZedCB, 2022-08
interesting and I agree with you. sorry if my original comment sounded like I was correcting you or something. I had my mind made up after watching an actual 90 mins panel[1] on this subject - then after watching I re-read both books and since then thought I finally had my answer to this annoying question. that is until you just tore it all up again with more facts I hadn't considered :) the prob… — DyslexicAtheist, 2019-02
- Most channels by IDW (Intelectual Dark Web) people, though when you know all the arguments, due to overwatching, it can get a bit tiring. - Tom Scott, igsquared, JunsKitchen, Alex French Cooking Guy, New York Times, Great Big Story, Strange Parts, TED, and a few philosophy ones from Brazil. Some examples: JunsKitchen (Japanese cooking), homemade tofu [LINK] Lateral (Tom Scott's new game show) [… — personlurking, 2018-06

Related videos