8LU - Are we *really* engineers? by Hillel Wayne
Channel:8th Light Inc. · Length:32:47 · Published:2020-06-26 · Views:9188
Summary
Hillel Wayne reports on interviews with 17 people who have worked as both software and traditional engineers. He argues the fields are fundamentally the same and have much to learn from each other.
Why HN recommends it
HN uses it as the reference for whether software is really engineering and how it differs from other disciplines.
There was a good talk on this subject last week — HN, 2020
Software practice, open source & careers · Civil engineering & construction
Subtitles (excerpt)
so first of all everybody thank you so much for coming um I think most of you already know me my name is Hillel I I'm mostly known for my work in formal methods and history I'm not talking about either of those today instead I want to talk about question that's been bothering me for a couple of years about is software engineering really engineering now this is a rough draft in fact it's an incredibly rough rough darf because on Thursday morning I realized that my first starpha which was much more bio and brimstone in my normal way of speaking wasn't actually a great way presenting information so I throw out everything and started over that means that everything you're gonna see is now extremely rough and is going to be a lot more conversational but I think overall it works much better for the format other thing worth noting is that there's currently about 75 people I see in the channel including a lot of people I respect a lot of friends a lot of Twitter friends and at least two people that I interviewed so I'm kind of terrified right now but it should all be okay so to start here's a question that I think a lot of people have asked how is software engineering different from civil engineering and this is a question
On Hacker News
Absolutely! Some companies are great at this but most (from my experience) use the term but there's 0 'engineering' involved - it's just hacking bits of code together and hoping it lives long enough for a customer to sign off on UAT. There was a good talk on this subject last week - here's the recording if you're interested [VIDEO] — exdsq, 2020-06
I really think you should read Dan's post in full . Because you really did make the error him and Hillel discuss. I think it'll also help interpret my point and the gp to my comment. We're not thinking in a framework where CS and Eng are all that different. Or skip to this part of Hillel's video[0] I've been an aerospace engineer. Worked there before coming over to CS. And I can certainty tell yo… — godelski, 2025-04
> and I have experience with construction as well. Just so we're clear, construction isn't engineering[0]. The difference does matter specifically in what we're talking about. > If your implication was followed in software (i.e. try to predict the future and introduce hidden floors, service floors and such) — and it sometimes is — we really end up with worse, more complex software that has techni… — godelski, 2025-04
I used to think this, and then I interviewed people who did both traditional and software engineering professionally, and now I'm not so sure. I did a first draft of what I learned here: [VIDEO] I'm hoping to have a written version by the end of September. — hwayne, 2020-07
Related videos
- 🚀 TDD, Where Did It All Go Wrong (Ian Cooper) · DevTernity Conference · 1:03:55
- Bret Victor The Future of Programming · Joey Reid · 32:55
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- "Uncle" Bob Martin - "The Future of Programming" · Paul Stringer's Mobile Tech · 1:18:21
- Tim Ewald - Clojure: Programming with Hand Tools · ClojureTV · 58:39
- Using Python to Code by Voice · Next Day Video · 28:17
- Transforming Code into Beautiful, Idiomatic Python · Next Day Video · 48:51
- Agile is Dead • Pragmatic Dave Thomas • GOTO 2015 · GOTO Conferences · 40:39
- 1. How Buildings Learn - Stewart Brand - 1 of 6 - “Flow” · Stewart Brand · 29:36
- Plover: Thought to Text at 240 WPM · Next Day Video · 34:21
- "The Economics of Programming Languages" by Evan Czaplicki (Strange Loop 2023) · Strange Loop Conference · 43:57
- "The Mess We're In" by Joe Armstrong · Strange Loop Conference · 45:50
- Principles of Technology Leadership | Bryan Cantrill | Monktoberfest 2017 · RedMonk Tech Events · 51:22
- A Talk Near the Future of Python (a.k.a., Dave live-codes a WebAssembly Interpreter) · David Beazley · 1:01:45
- What Really Happened During the Texas Power Grid Outage? · Practical Engineering · 16:47
- The Art of Code - Dylan Beattie · NDC Conferences · 1:00:48