DEBUNKING STARLINK
Channel:Common Sense Skeptic · Length:43:14 · Published:2021-07-04 · Views:717016
Summary
A 43-minute skeptical critique arguing that Starlink fails to live up to its promises, covering satellite lifespan, costs, bandwidth and viability. The creator later added an update about FCC grant requirements.
Why HN recommends it
A few commenters recommend it as a skeptical take on Starlink economics, though others see it as dishonest.
watching Common Sense Skeptic’s video, which I recommend — HN, 2021
Networking & internet infrastructure · Tech industry & business models · Space exploration & spaceflight
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] welcome to this episode of the common sense skeptic this episode is going to be dedicated to musk's internet constellation called starlink which we touched on in our colonizing mars series we touched on it because this is the service where musk wrote the outline for free and independent mars into one of the sections of the service agreement we are going to take this topic on from a couple of different angles the economic model the benefits over competitors and the hazards that this system presents if it is allowed to continue forward musk has convinced his followers that starlink will provide the economic boon that spacex needs to finance all their future space endeavors several articles believe that this is a 30 billion dollar cash cow for the company by the year 2025 so just four years from now we are going to demonstrate that they are kidding themselves if they think this is going to happen and we're going to start with an historical precedent apparently the core of his followers suffer from a lack of long-term memory because they've been played like this before it wasn't that long ago that they believed musk when he was selling them leases and ppas for solar panel systems through solar city while
On Hacker News
Few days ago I watched 'Debunking Starlink' video [0] (posted by @qsdf38100 in another thread [1] on Starlink) and it got me thinking. I am just a lay person, but, after watching it, am not so sure if Starlink is such a good idea. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — gala8y, 2022-01
I’ve been fairly skeptical about Starlink since watching Common Sense Skeptic’s video, which I recommend: [VIDEO] — taliesinb, 2021-08
This video[0] seems to disagree with this. In particular it seems like there's a lot of recurring costs involved and this infrastructure is not super stable (the video talks about satelites having a shelf life of 5 years. We're not rebuilding fiber out every 5 years!) The videos "has an agenda" but it seems a bit easy to accept the idea that constantly launching satelites into space is pretty exp… — rtpg, 2022-05
I recently started researching into Starlink as my next (cheap) internet solution and stumbled upon these 2 videos below. The worst part for me is that once this becomes more popular the bandwidth will die down to crumble. I don't buy they will be able to upkeep with bandwidth sharing it from satellite to satellite using a.. laser beam (is that even possible to sync 2 satellites and send signal t… — joering2, 2022-02
> If he lies He lies; that is very core to my point and it isn't an if. Just fact check him. He lies. I'll save you some time: Here is a link to an article he screenshots: [LINK] Here is the time where he shows the screenshot: [VIDEO] Here is a sample from the debunking article about him which I linked in my first post: > 7:16 - CSS claims that the reported aspirational costs for the satellites i… — JoshCole, 2022-07
Related videos
- Violence | Slavoj Žižek | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:17:11
- Oswald Acted Alone: JFK Assassination Solved (Part 1 of 2) · Sean Munger · 1:43:56
- Brains, Sex, and Machine Learning · Google TechTalks · 1:00:19
- Yanis Varoufakis: The Global Minotaur: America, Europe and the Future of the Global Economy · SkriptaTV · 57:27
- Light Years Ahead | The 1969 Apollo Guidance Computer · TNMoC · 1:21:22
- YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is. · Tom Scott · 42:29
- Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:00:56
- Harder Drive: Hard drives we didn't want or need · suckerpinch · 36:46
- The Solar Gravitational Lens will Map Exoplanets. Seriously. · Launch Pad Astronomy · 23:32
- The Problem With Facebook · 2veritasium · 6:59
- This Video Is Sponsored By ███ VPN · Tom Scott · 7:25
- 34C3 - The Ultimate Apollo Guidance Computer Talk · media.ccc.de · 1:01:41
- VidMe or Why Platforms Aren't Your Friends · Folding Ideas · 15:47
- Falcon Heavy Test Flight · SpaceX · 34:19
- Sinclair Broadcast Group: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 18:59
- I Was SCARED To Say This To NASA... (But I said it anyway) - Smarter Every Day 293 · SmarterEveryDay · 1:05:19