Lisp Editing in the 80s - Interlisp SEdit

Channel:thoughtupquick · Length:4:53 · Published:2017-06-22 · Views:9057

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short demo of SEdit, the structure editor for Interlisp-D on Xerox Lisp machines in the 1980s, which edits code as trees rather than text.

Why HN recommends it

Linked as the clearest view of the legendary structural editor in threads about Lisp environments and structure editing.

Dan Ingalls (one of the original authors of Smalltalk) in a 2017 demo of Smalltalk 76 — HN, 2021

Functional programming · Testing, debugging & developer tools · History of computing

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello my name is Brian Masten Brook and I'd like to demonstrate a few features of the S expression editor of the interlist programming environment here running under the medley emulator to start off with running in the emulator here we need to make a listener we get a couple different options for language to choose in lisp old in lisp and two different dialects of common lisp drag a new window for The Listener and we have a standard listener one thing to note is that when you hit the right parand to close an expression it will automatically evaluate so from the editor here we can Define functions we can also invoke the S expression Editor to bring up a interactive Editor to create a new function definition we'll do this as follows once we hit the close parand we have the option to create a new dummy definition for the symbol in this case a uh function definition and since we're off the screen here we'll shape it back onto the screen and here we have a dummy definition but this definition is a little bit different we're actually editing the S expression so we can put the cursor at a point anywhere here hit the delete key a few times when we delete over the opening quote the entire quote disappears

On Hacker News

That's a good suggestion. Walking through a set of interactions is a solid idea. For what it's worth, there are some videos around of people actually doing it with Lisp and Smalltalk systems, and pjmlp already posted a pile of them elsewhere in this thread. I can add a few more: Kalman Reti walking through some interactions with a Symbolics LispM repl: [LINK] Brian Mastenbrook demonstrating Inter… — mikelevins, 2021-01
I missed the golden age of lisp, but i know this project for its legendary structural editor, SEdit[1], released the year I was born. i found it mentioned in an old paredit readme, something poignant like “paredit is only a shadow of what interlisp was: true structural editing”. [1]: [VIDEO] — undershirt, 2020-08
> I-Expressions That's not an EXPLICIT list representation, where the nesting is notated by explicit characters. It's also harder to use in interactive interfaces like REPLs, debuggers, etc., where Lisp lists don't need to have vertical layout. > you do have syntax errors--unbalanced parens. if you use a structure editor for Lisp you don't have unbalanced parentheses. In editors with support for … — lispm, 2019-10

Related videos