I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate
Channel:AlphaPhoenix · Length:22:48 · Published:2021-12-17 · Views:3703157
Summary
AlphaPhoenix builds a scaled-down version of the Veritasium electricity thought experiment using about a kilometer of wire and an oscilloscope. He measures how the signal actually propagates and explains the result.
Why HN recommends it
HN considers it the best experimental rebuttal and clarification of the Veritasium wire debate, with real measurements.
Yeah I really liked the AlphaPheonix video[0] where he actually built the thing in a field and explained the entire effect properly. — HN, 2023
Electronics & circuit design · Fundamental physics
Subtitles (excerpt)
two weeks ago as i filmed this derrick over on veritasium proposed a physics thought experiment and today i have made that into a real experiment he proposed a simple circuit where you have a battery a switch and a light bulb except the wires that connect these components together are really really really long and stretch far away in both directions such that if the power from the battery when you flip the switch had to go all the way down the wire and back you'd actually be able to see a delay before the light bulb turned on if you had to wait for light speed effectively to make that round trip as i watched that video i was extremely unconvinced i think that his answer that you don't need to wait for the light speed delay is technically correct if you use his very carefully crafted definitions like any current passing through the light bulb constitutes the light bulb turning on now the bulb won't receive the entire voltage of the battery immediately but i think that there's a whole lot more to this question and your intuition about the answer is probably not quite as wrong as you've been led to believe so i'm about to fire this circuit up i have an oscilloscope that can do very precise timings and i have about a kilometer
On Hacker News
[VIDEO] AlphaPhoenix did an amazing experiment to measure the speed of electricity FWIW. His other videos are incredible as well and explain EM physics in an absolutely outstanding way. — reaperman, 2024-07
Yeah I really liked the AlphaPheonix video[0] where he actually built the thing in a field and explained the entire effect properly. I'm not entirely sure if Derek didn't really understand what he was presenting in that video or deliberately based it on a really misleading bullshit gotcha to troll people and stir debate for clicks, and neither reflects very well on him. [0] [VIDEO] — moffkalast, 2023-12
The video in question for reference: [LINK] Interestingly, when I saw that I figured this channel for a goner because he was going to turn to the darkside, but quite contrary to expectations I feel like his channel has actually blossomed since then. His older videos are fine, but often just explaining concepts that you can find a lot of other explanations on, but some of his recent videos have ro… — jerf, 2023-09
Looking at the discussion below this comment, I'd just add this video by AlphaPheonix: [VIDEO] Good discussion in the comments there as well. — sbuttgereit, 2026-04
Yes, you can see one of the best people do a demonstration of it [VIDEO] It's close enough to c that you should just use c but it can be observed that it's less. — Spivak, 2025-02
Related videos
- Jonathan Haidt: The moral roots of liberals and conservatives · TED · 19:14
- Clickbait is Unreasonably Effective · Veritasium · 19:25
- The Unreasonable Efficiency of Black Holes · minutephysics · 6:22
- How Electricity Actually Works · Veritasium · 24:30
- Government Surveillance: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 33:14
- How Not to Land an Orbital Rocket Booster · SpaceX · 2:09
- Spherical Geometry Is Stranger Than Hyperbolic - Hyperbolica Devlog #2 · CodeParade · 4:00
- The Biggest Misconception About Electricity · Veritasium · 14:48
- Thinking outside the 10-dimensional box · 3Blue1Brown · 25:13
- Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light · Veritasium · 19:05
- Why Snow and Confetti Ruin YouTube Video Quality · Tom Scott · 4:20
- The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013) · Mladen Mijatov · 45:35
- Fractals are typically not self-similar · 3Blue1Brown · 19:55
- Why CG Sucks (Except It Doesn't) · RocketJump Film School · 7:40
- Infinite fractions and the most irrational number · Mathologer · 13:29
- Chicken chicken chicken · Yoram Bauman · 4:06
- 15 Sorting Algorithms in 6 Minutes · Timo Bingmann · 5:50
- Lenses, Folds, and Traversals · Edward Kmett · 1:54:45
- Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS! · suckerpinch · 22:21
- How Star Wars was saved in the edit · RocketJump · 18:24