Where Do Trees Get Their Mass?

Channel:Veritasium · Length:4:10 · Published:2012-03-12 · Views:2554021

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium asks people where a tree's mass comes from, then explains that most of a dry tree's mass originates from carbon dioxide in the air. It combines street interviews with a short explanation of photosynthesis.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to demonstration of how unintuitive mass conservation is, especially in weight loss and burning threads.

Veritasium has a fun video demonstrating how unintuitive this is — HN, 2017

Everyday physics & science demos · Biology & biotechnology · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Trees are some of the biggest organisms on the planet, but where do they get that matter to grow? Man: Rich nutrients out the ground. Man: Start with soil or in the air. Man: Goodness out of the soil, I suppose. Derek Muller: Comes out of the soil? Man: Yeah... Derek Muller: Yeah... Derek Muller: Goodness. Man: Goodness. Derek Muller: Why isn't there a big hole around the tree where it's taking out all the soil? Man (right): 'Cause it does it so gradually that the soil is time to recover. Derek Muller: Now, I think it's intuitive to believe that the tree gets most of its mass from the soil because you can see those roots digging into the soil and they must be taking something out of there and I mean a tree looks like dirt and it feels solid like dirt but it's not. In the early 1600 a scientist named Johann Baptist Van Helmholt tried to figure out where the mass of a tree was coming from so he got a pot of soil and very carefully measured the amount of soil in there. Then he planted the tree and took care of it for five years making sure that no soil left or was added to his pot . At the end of this experiment he was weighted the tree to find that it was 72 kilograms but the massive soil had only decreased by about 60 grams.

On Hacker News

"Where do trees get their mass?" - [VIDEO] This was highly enlightening the first time I watched it :) — lathiat, 2021-04
An interesting corollary to this is "Where do trees get their mass?" Veritasium has a fun video demonstrating how unintuitive this is: [VIDEO] — JshWright, 2017-11
There's a nice Veritasium episode wherein he asks people on the street where a tree's mass comes from: [VIDEO] (This isn't just one of those "let's laugh at how dumb people on the street are" videos; it's done explicitly as a learning exercise. His PhD looked at how addressing misconceptions and going from there to correct explanations works much better than simply providing explanations: [LINK] … — lkbm, 2015-04
And the reverse biochemical process is equally misunderstood. I used to teach high school Science and everyone thought a tree's mass came from the soil. [VIDEO] — MarcScott, 2015-04

Related videos