Geoff Hinton: On Radiology
Channel:Creative Destruction Lab · Length:1:24 · Published:2016-11-24 · Views:45815
Summary
A one-minute clip from a 2016 Toronto conference in which Geoff Hinton comments on deep learning and radiology. He suggests radiologists should stop being trained because machines would soon read scans better.
Why HN recommends it
HN uses it as a famous example of an overconfident AI prediction that turned out wrong, since radiologists remain in demand.
Machine learning & deep learning · AI safety, AGI & impact · Medicine & infectious disease
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] so Jeff perhaps a similar question if you may what what do you think Sim exciting work uh to come okay so um sorry um let me start by just saying a few things that seem obvious um I think if you work as a radiologist you're like the coyote that's already over the edge of the cliff but hasn't yet looked down so doesn't realize there's no ground underneath him um people should stop training Radiologists now it's just completely obvious that within 5 years um deep learning is going to do better than Radiologists because it's going to be able to get a lot more experience um it might be 10 years but we got plenty of Radiologists already um I said this at a hospital and it didn't go down Too Well they um there's going to be thousands of applications of the deep learning technology we currently have especially stuff using um fast chips um to thousands of applications and hundreds of them are going to work and those are the ones you're going to hear about um so there'll be lots of that and I think of that now as business as usual take any old problem where you have to predict something and you have a lot of data and deep learning is probably going to make it work better than the existing [Music]
On Hacker News
He seems pretty unequivocal in the video: [VIDEO] . He even points out that it’s something which he’s claimed previously, ruling out the idea that it was some kind of spur-of-the-moment conclusion. — leoc, 2026-06
"It’s also important to be patient. College is an investment that pays dividends over your entire working life. If you’re a new graduate, you’ve just incurred the upfront costs of this investment in your human capital, but you have many decades to go to reap the economic benefits of your college degree. " I must admit, that triggered me. I say that is by far a too comfortable assertion. > It defi… — observation, 2017-05
> I'm quite far from a technological utopian, but when Hinton states that radiologists should halt their training, he is not joking. > [VIDEO] Thanks for pointing to that clip. Hadn't seen that — sndean, 2017-05
I guess it's worth reminding people that in 2016, Geoff Hinton said some pretty arrogant things that turned out to be totally wrong: Let me start by saying a few things that seem obvious. I think if you work as a radiologist, you're like the coyote that’s already over the edge of the cliff but hasn’t yet looked down It’s just completely obvious that within five years deep learning is going to do … — chubot, 2025-09
I remember when Hinton said that that we should "stop training radiologists now" in 2016[1]. Meanwhile, radiologists are in high demand and are getting paid better than ever. I believe the same will be true for programmers in the future. Sure, some of the boilerplate will be handled for you, just like segmentation is for radiologists. That's great for everyone. 1 = [VIDEO] — carbocation, 2025-01
Related videos
- The spelled-out intro to neural networks and backpropagation: building micrograd · Andrej Karpathy · 2:25:52
- But what is a neural network? | Deep learning chapter 1 · 3Blue1Brown · 18:40
- Sugar: THE BITTER TRUTH · University of California Television (UCTV) · 1:29:36
- What Happened to Horses Is Happening to Us · CGP Grey · 15:00
- AlphaGo - The Movie | Full award-winning documentary · Google DeepMind · 1:30:28
- We Were Taught to Call Death a Blessing · CGP Grey · 12:43
- Transformers, the tech behind LLMs | Deep Learning Chapter 5 · 3Blue1Brown · 27:14
- USENIX Security '18-Q: Why Do Keynote Speakers Keep Suggesting That Improving Security Is Possible? · USENIX · 51:22
- Lecture 1 | Machine Learning (Stanford) · Stanford · 1:08:40
- MarI/O - Machine Learning for Video Games · SethBling · 5:57
- Deep Dive into LLMs like ChatGPT · Andrej Karpathy · 3:31:23
- Computer program that learns to play classic NES games · suckerpinch · 16:17
- Dr. Michael Greger | How Not To Die | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:21:13
- RL Course by David Silver - Lecture 1: Introduction to Reinforcement Learning · Google DeepMind · 1:28:12
- Why Some Diseases Only Traveled One Direction · CGP Grey · 11:12
- Let's build GPT: from scratch, in code, spelled out. · Andrej Karpathy · 1:56:20