Why you shouldn't water cool your PC

Channel:Linus Tech Tips · Length:13:59 · Published:2019-04-30 · Views:9625336

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Linus Tech Tips argues that big air coolers beat AIO liquid coolers for most PCs. They compare quietness and temperatures, using the Noctua NH-U12A as the example.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as evidence that a good air cooler matches pricier liquid cooling, so water cooling is often unnecessary.

Good air coolers match the performance of twice as expensive AIOs — HN, 2021

Computer architecture & CPUs · Consumer devices & gadgets

Subtitles (excerpt)

So, you're building a brand new PC, and it's time to choose a cooler for your CPU. There are so many options out there, but before you even really get into the weeds, you've got to make one choice. Do you cool your PC with a large air cooler or with an all-in-one liquid cooler? Now, if we can trust the marketing, AIOs are the clear choice. Water transfers heat so much better than air, right? But is that the entire story? Maybe, actually. I I don't know. Alex has been working on this in isolation, and I don't know the test results. So, I'm just as eager to find out as you guys are. Now, before you run out and buy a new CPU cooler, you need to first figure out if your CPU is going to get any benefit from additional cooling. Now, in the old days, inadequate cooling was a recipe for instant catastrophic failure, because the modern protection or throttling mechanisms that prevent them from exceeding the generally accepted maximum of 100° C didn't exist yet. But, just because both Intel and AMD seem to agree that their processors will last at least through their warranty period at that temperature, doesn't mean having it there is a great idea. The hotter an integrated circuit runs, the more power it will consume, and the

On Hacker News

> The motherboard is also their custom chipset It's a custom motherboard but not a custom chipset. The chipset comes from AMD. > I'd also be keen to swap the Ryzen 3700 for the newer series chip .. but have no clue whether that is possible on that motherboard If the chipset is A520, B550 or X570, you have Ryzen 5000 / Zen 3 support, though it probably requires a BIOS update. You might also have Z… — 66fm472tjy7, 2021-04
I'd expect it to be pretty high: given reviews, I went with the stock Wraith Prism, and it's been fine. If I did bump up, I'd go to a Noctua, as the water cooling just seems like theater. [VIDEO] — pkroll, 2020-02
Linus Tech Tips recently published a video called "why you shouldn't water cool your PC"; they found that a Noctua NH-U12A ran cooler and quieter than an AIO liquid cooler. [VIDEO] — jdietrich, 2019-05

Related videos