Five Stages of Accepting Constructive Mathematics - Andrej Bauer

Channel:Institute for Advanced Study · Length:57:31 · Published:2016-08-16 · Views:34209

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Andrej Bauer's IAS talk introduces constructive mathematics and what it feels like to do mathematics without excluded middle. It is framed as a tour for classical mathematicians.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to as a well-done introduction to constructive mathematics when it comes up in logic and proof assistant threads.

Here are two versions of the same well-done talk, from Andrej Bauer — HN, 2018

Pure mathematics · Logic & formal methods

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you and thank you very much for inviting me here um I decided to talk about constructive mathematics from the point of view of an ordinary mathematician so somebody who is primarily not interested so much in philosophy and logic but just wants to do math um so I want to tell you a little bit about what it's like to work in constructive mathematics and um which aspects of it are relevant to mathematics in general so I hope you're at least a little bit curious about this topic I also apologize in advance for not being able to hide my positive feelings about constructive mathematics but feel free to interpret me and ask questions except if you are a seasoned constructivist and you want to make a fine point about meta mathematics this talk I would like to keep it at the level of math not at the level of logic or philosophy um so somebody asked me whether this is like Nine Circles um it's five stages of the psychologist Elizabeth Kubler Ross who identified the stages of accepting death and these are denial anger bargaining depression and acceptance so not everyone goes through all these stages and they don't necessarily come in this order but they can be applied to many other situations such as learning uh but before we get into psychology I do want to review

On Hacker News

There are a lot of folks here asking for a bit more. Here are two versions of the same well-done talk, from Andrej Bauer: a video [VIDEO] , and a paper [LINK] (sorry, the paper link may not work for everyone, but the video contains basically the same content.) — jimhefferon, 2018-11
Five stages of accepting constructive mathematics: Denial Anger Bargaining Depression Acceptance A talk about constructive mathematics by Andrej Bauer at the Institute for Advanced Study. [VIDEO] [LINK] — leonidasrup, 2026-04
That depends on what you mean by "Church-Turing thesis": * [LINK] The Interactive Nature of Computing: Refuting the Strong Church-Turing Thesis (Published version here: [LINK] ) * [LINK] See also a previous hacker news discussion of the Church-Turing thesis here: [LINK] albeit I take issue with the supposed "proof" by counter example via Compass & Straightedge construction given in the video ther… — no_identd, 2019-01

Related videos