The Trolley Problem in Real Life

Channel:Vsauce · Length:34:38 · Published:2017-12-06 · Views:15858686

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Vsauce's Michael Stevens stages a realistic version of the trolley problem with unsuspecting subjects who believe they must decide a life-or-death outcome. The Mind Field episode compares what people say they would do with what they actually do.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a worthwhile real-world experiment whenever trolley problems or moral dilemmas come up.

The video is well worth a watch — HN, 2021

Psychology & human behavior · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

[sneezes] Excuse me. You know, if I had been driving, that would've been pretty dangerous. Every time you sneeze, your eyes close for about one second, which means if you sneeze while driving at, say, 70 miles per hour times 5,280 divided by 60 divided by 60, you will travel about 103 feet with your eyes closed. But don't worry. This is a self-driving car. It uses sensors and software to drive itself to keep me and other people safe. I hope. [tires screech] Impressive. But let me ask you a question. What if an autonomous vehicle had to make a choice between hitting two people right in front of it or swerving to avoid them and hit one person on a sidewalk? What should it be programmed to do? [tires screech, car crashes] What would you do? Now polls and surveys have been put together asking people what they think they would do, but no researchers have ever put people in that actual traumatic experience. Would we learn more about human nature if we did that? Would it even be ethical to put people in that sort of position? I'm about to find out. [theme music playing] In 1967, British philosopher Philippa Foot created a precursor to our self-driving car conundrum. The famous scenario she came up with is known as "the trolley problem."

On Hacker News

> Perhaps something to think about in a scenario like this. Personally I think it's interesting that some people are so quick to condone aggressive attacks on powerful people, yet have no comment on those powerful people committing lower levels of violence against the masses. It's all social context. Can I just say that out of all of this discourse happening, this might be the most insightful yet… — Imustaskforhelp, 2026-04
They did this experiment in real life [VIDEO] . It's not 100% perfect but it is still an amazing test. — Sceptique, 2022-07
The youtube channel vsauce tried putting people in this situation by putting them in a fake railroad switching outpost and having the operator step out for a phonecall. They took care to educate the subject exactly on how the system works without them suspecting anything, trying to eliminate many of the factors you mention. The video is well worth a watch [VIDEO] — wongarsu, 2021-02

Related videos