Are we stuck with the same Desktop UX forever? | Ubuntu Summit 25.10

Channel:Canonical Ubuntu · Length:43:30 · Published:2025-12-11 · Views:510853

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Scott Jenson, a veteran UX designer formerly at Apple and Google, argues that the 'UX/UI' split pits programmers against designers and narrows ambition in open source. He makes the case that desktop UX has stagnated and that open source projects could lead experimentation beyond current interaction models.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it when discussing stagnating desktop UX, Apple's design decline, and open source's chance to experiment with new interaction models.

It's time for open source projects to embrace experimentation and take the mantle of cutting edge UX — HN, 2026

Linux & open-source ecosystems · GUI, HCI & interface history · UX & UI design

Subtitles (excerpt)

So, as he said, I'd worked at these various companies for most of my professional life. I've kind of gone over to open source to kind of atoned for my sins. Um, these companies were cool when I was young. They're less cool now. Um, I now spend I've I've now uh partially retired. I do mentoring for young UX designers. I work with Maston Home Assistant. And the reason why I think I'm here though is that back in the 80s and the 90s I worked at Apple and I did an awful lot of work on desktop UX. So I've got some more stories to tell and things like that. And one of the things that I thought was interesting to bring up was back um I I'd actually forgotten that I'd made this change to the Finder back in the 19 early 80s. Um, basically what happened was the the finder team was found out that there was the name wasn't going to fit and they wanted to put ellipses on the end of the file and I was like there's just too much critical information here so why don't you put the ellipsus in the middle and the finder team was so easy to work with and they were like cool and they implemented it within like a day or two and I promptly forgot all about it and then about last year someone was saying here's a good example of why

On Hacker News

I’ve always respected macOS for being the 'stable' choice for not-as-techy people. But recent versions feel like a mess. Running Tahoe on my 2019 Mac Pro (Yes the cheese grater one) has been surprisingly frustrating. Simple things are broken: Ableton couldn't even trigger a microphone permission prompt, forcing me to meddle with a SQLite database, which is definitely not meant for end users to to… — finnlab, 2026-01
Scott Jenson - who worked on the classic Mac for Apple, and Android for Google - recently gave a talk on this: [VIDEO] The tl;dw is that copying UX lets others invest energy in identifying the paradigm. Linux, which tends to be starved for resources, has historically been reasonably well served by letting Apple and Microsoft define UX, while Linux focuses on implementing it. However, those headli… — bsimpson, 2026-01
It may have jumped the shark, but it may be that now there's space for actual experimentation and innovation again. This talk from Scott Jenson (who worked at Apple in Human Interfaces) was thought-provoking and gave me a little optimism: [VIDEO] — glkindlmann, 2026-01
This feels like a step in the right direction from this talk on desktop UX. Finally some cool innovation here! [VIDEO] — eighty8days, 2026-07
> "we have to cater to what 96% of users know" Indeed. Just recently saw a talk "Are we stuck with the same Desktop UX forever? | Ubuntu Summit 25.10" ( [VIDEO] ) where Scott Jenson (Apple/Google UX) laments we stopped innovating on Desktop. Such appeal to conformity is indeed quite sad from GNOME. — jaywee, 2026-01

Related videos