The Bizarre Behavior of Rotating Bodies

Channel:Veritasium · Length:14:48 · Published:2019-09-19 · Views:14022018

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium explains the Dzhanibekov effect, also called the tennis racket theorem, where a spinning object flips unexpectedly about its intermediate axis. The video gives an intuitive account of the underlying rotational dynamics, drawing on Terry Tao's explanation and the original papers.

Why HN recommends it

HN people cite it as the clearest layperson-friendly explanation of rotational instability whenever spinning bodies, tumbling objects or axis shifts come up.

Derek Muller on the youtube channel Veritasium has a good video on this — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos

Subtitles (excerpt)

I want to thank the sponsor of this episode, LastPass, which remembers your passwords so you don't have to More about them at the end of the show What you are looking at is known as the Dzhanibekov effect or the tennis racket theorem or the intermediate axis theorem but we'll get to that Now you may have seen clips like this one before, but in this video I will provide the best intuitive explanation of how this effect works or, at least, that's my goal. Now it involves arguably the best mathematician alive, Soviet era secrets, and the end of the world So in 1985, cosmonaut Vladimir Dzhanibekov was tasked with saving the Soviet space station Salyut 7 which had completely shut down The mission was so dramatic that the Russians made a movie out of it in 2017 and after rescuing the space station, Dzhanibekov unpacked supplies sent up from Earth which were locked down with a wing-nut and as the wing-nut spun off the bolt, he noticed something strange: the wing-nut maintained its orientation for a short time, and then it flipped, 180 degrees. And as he kept watching, it flipped back a few seconds later and it continued flipping back and forth at regular intervals this motion wasn't caused by forces or torques

On Hacker News

Not me. I only understand half your post, to tell you the truth. But Derek Muller on the youtube channel Veritasium has a good video on this, where he mentions how, when asked one time, Feynman couldn't think of a simple way to describe how it works, and then Muller goes on to explain it in a way that I could see. Great stuff: [VIDEO] — BubbleRings, 2024-01
More seriously though, rotating habs are more difficult to spin properly than Clarke knew. The Russians discovered this and kept it to themselves. [VIDEO] I personally like the idea of spinning up large asteroids but the Dzhanibekov Effect will cause a lot of sloshing. If I understand it right, you have to spin them along the long axis, not like O’Neill cylinders. Two separate habitats at opposit… — hinkley, 2025-07
I was just about to suggest the same thing. Here's a related Veritasium episode: "The Bizarre Behavior of Rotating Bodies" [VIDEO] — HarHarVeryFunny, 2024-06
You don't necessarily need gravity to make something tilt, it can happen naturally during rotation. For instance, imagine spinning something that distorts asymmetrically, like a pencil with some silly putty attached to one side. Alternatively, there's stuff like this: [VIDEO] . Angular momentum's always conserved, but the axis of rotation might not be. — Paedor, 2021-09
> Researchers monitored the known repeater FRB 121102 with the Lovell Telescope, a 250-foot-wide (76 meters) radio dish at Jodrell Bank Observatory in England, over the course of five years. They found strong indications of a 157-day activity cycle; 121102 seems to flare up for 90 days and then go silent for 67, the team reported in a new study. > It's unclear what's behind such cyclic activity, … — raghava, 2020-06

Related videos