Gregory Chaitin - Is Mathematics Invented or Discovered?
Channel:Closer To Truth · Length:11:52 · Published:2019-09-28 · Views:53804
Summary
Gregory Chaitin is interviewed on Closer To Truth about whether mathematics is invented or discovered. He gives a nuanced view that ties the question to the nature of reality.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters recommend it as a thoughtful and nuanced take on the philosophy of mathematics.
The whole interview is actually quite nuanced on the question of whether math is discovered or invented and well worth a watch — HN, 2021
Pure mathematics · Philosophy & ethics
Subtitles (excerpt)
Greig most of the mathematicians I talked to certainly the physicists also say that math is is at the foundation of reality that it is exists in a platonic world that it is is the perfect expression of reality what do you say well is it invented or discovered you know when you find when you're a mathematician you find something that feels really fundamental you may think that if you hadn't found it somebody else would because in some sense it's got to it's got to be there but some mathematics feels much more contrived you know like an exercise that you do to be able to publish a paper so I would say that there's an element from that point of view there's nominative truth in age but then there's the question of I I sort of I think both ideas I sort of swing both ways on this but that's okay you know we all recognize there's a lot of things that are that are invented papers the question is is anything in mathematics truly discovered truly sitting there forever is there anything of that nature or is everything sort of an approximation that our senses sort of perceive in the universe that's the question there anything in mathematics that's so fundamental that it's discovered well I I think that a lot of us mathematicians we may not want to confess
On Hacker News
Gregory Chaitin has an interesting take on this: "The only place where medieval theology survives is pure math." [VIDEO] (The whole interview is actually quite nuanced on the question of whether math is discovered or invented and well worth a watch. There are also interviews with other mathematicians and physicists in the series, for example with Roger Penrose, but most other researchers seem to … — skoodge, 2021-10
You got me to chuckle at, "thought terminating thought experiment". I will file that in my cliché attaché. Are you saying that I am asking for a universal perfect compressor, like I am winning the Hutter Prize [1] ? I don't believe I said that. To add to the tooling, what if the forum itself "learned you", and took that into account when I respond. It would know everything you wrote, potentially … — seg_lol, 2020-10
Entire playlist: * [LINK] Gregory Chaitin was interesting as well: * [VIDEO] The (apocryphal?) story about Godel not believing in empirical science and only in a priori truths was interesting. — throw0101a, 2020-04
Related videos
- Vectors | Chapter 1, Essence of linear algebra · 3Blue1Brown · 9:51
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- Justice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode 01 "THE MORAL SIDE OF MURDER" · Harvard University · 54:56
- Lec 1 | MIT 18.06 Linear Algebra, Spring 2005 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 39:49
- We Were Taught to Call Death a Blessing · CGP Grey · 12:43
- Alain de Botton: Status Anxiety · Alain de Botton · 2:23:07
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- Music and Life - Alan Watts · seandulac · 2:23
- The essence of calculus · 3Blue1Brown · 17:04
- Siggraph2019 Geometric Algebra · Bivector · 1:37:21
- Category Theory 1.1: Motivation and Philosophy · Bartosz Milewski · 46:46
- Essence of linear algebra preview · 3Blue1Brown · 5:09
- A Swift Introduction to Geometric Algebra · sudgylacmoe · 44:23
- The hardest problem on the hardest test · 3Blue1Brown · 11:15
- Imaginary Numbers Are Real [Part 1: Introduction] · Welch Labs · 5:47
- The Egg - A Short Story · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 8:06