YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is.

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:42:29 · Published:2020-03-23 · Views:9003901

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott's long explainer on YouTube's copyright system, Content ID and the DMCA. He argues the platform's system is a workaround for a broader copyright system that does not fit the modern world.

Why HN recommends it

The default link in copyright and takedown threads, recommended as an excellent, comprehensive explanation of why automated enforcement and the law work as they do.

Tom Scott explains the situation and the solution best. — HN, 2020

Internet culture & memes · Tech industry & business models · Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm not saying that's how it should be. I'm saying that's how it is. So. How do we fix it? What's up, world? It's your boy Tom— Oh, come on! This video is sponsored by CuriosityStream, and by this: my new Nebula streaming series that you can watch for free when you join. More on that later. Sellout! What's up world? It's your boy, TomReacts. Let's see what this prat has to say. A few disclaimers before we start: While this video has been proofed and fact-checked by a team of legal experts, I am not a lawyer, and this is not a substitute for legal advice. Yeah, I can tell that, mate. I'm also talking a lot about YouTube and Google, companies that I benefit from enormously. Google even sponsored an entire series on this channel last year. Shill! I'm friends with a few YouTube employees. 'Course you are. So, while all the words here are my own, YouTube don't even know I'm making this, you should know that if you're one of the outliers who's been screwed over by YouTube's copyright system… Yeah, you will probably have a different view of parts of this. Although I hope you'll still agree with my conclusion. With all that said, enjoy the show. Get on with it! Not you. I realise saying "YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken"

On Hacker News

I recommend the excellent video by Youtuber Tom Scott "YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is." [VIDEO] While I agree with the OP in broad strokes (they clearly have the right to post and profit off their performance), I find that the vast majority of comments on Youtube's copyright claim system fail to even acknowledge major aspects of the problem. Perhaps Youtube's practical mo… — Laremere, 2021-06
A really great video (if you're willing to spend the better part of an hour watching it) about this is YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is.[1] by Tom Scott. [1] [VIDEO] — 0xTJ, 2021-05
[VIDEO] Tom Scott explains the situation and the solution best. Just shorten copyright to 20 years (instead of life + 70 years). .......that said, we did just strong-arm the world into matching US copyright law and I’m not sure we could do that now even if we wanted to. — jimbob45, 2020-11
> youtube algo's screwing up content creator A slightly different problem, but Tom Scott did an excellent video on the automation of the copyright system on YouTube: [VIDEO] In summary, auto copyright checking solves Most copyright issues, to a degree that no other solution can really provide. And while there are a small (yet very unfair) number of false positives, the benefit that the system as … — peterkos, 2020-05
> many unintuitive parts I think a more concrete term for unintuitive is outdated. The use cases for Copyright law were defined a century ago when society and technology was different. It is difficult for current citizens to understand copyright law because has nothing to do with their own day to day experiences and needs. Great video about Copyright by Tom Scott: [VIDEO] Too long didn't see: Cop… — Hokusai, 2020-03

Related videos